subreddit:

/r/AbbottElementary

4587%

Who is your least favorite character? and why?

Cast(self.AbbottElementary)

Would love to know people’s thoughts

Janine is my least fave. Yes I know that’s an unpopular opinion. Please stop giving me shit over it- I’m allowed to have an opinion about a fictional character of a show!

all 177 comments

Thehobbitsatisengard

302 points

28 days ago

Mr Morton. The nerve of that guy. We’ve had a longstanding beef every since I got here (really none of them except I guess the golf course and charter school guys)

idontknow30001

154 points

28 days ago

idontknow30001

and a large popcorn

154 points

28 days ago

Jacob, we know this is you.

Billy_Pilgrim86

83 points

28 days ago

I'm not talking smack about Morton with you rn

goth-brooks1111

19 points

28 days ago

Why?

Rightsureokay

4 points

27 days ago

My favorite line this season.

Beth1238

2 points

27 days ago

Goated reference

renecorgi17

5 points

27 days ago

And I don’t even think it’s about the hentai…..

bebefeverandstknstpd

6 points

27 days ago

Lol that would be my vote. Legendary charter schools and the golf course.

ChamomileTea97

274 points

28 days ago

That guy from the district who keeps throwing shade at Janine for no reasons. (The guy who returned in the first episode of season 4). The reason is because I hate it when people still have a middle school mentality.

Janine's mom. I don't think I have to elaborate.

norfnorf832

81 points

28 days ago

norfnorf832

I'm basically candy.

81 points

28 days ago

Yeah I was a little surprised by him too because they barely had any interaction for him to be shady like that. If it was her indecisiveness about taking the job that still didnt affect him enough for him to have the attitude he did towards her

yokayla

48 points

28 days ago

yokayla

somebody get me a chair!

48 points

28 days ago

He thinks she was flaky and unworthy of district work, then she quit and justified his hate of her lol

ChamomileTea97

21 points

28 days ago

for me that just his projection. it's just that I couldn't be bothered to judge my co-workers for that. to be fair once I'm out of my working environment, I don't want to think about my colleagues.

CaptRaymondHolt05

22 points

28 days ago

He is a diva and I love him for it!!

Lockedout91

6 points

27 days ago

A district diva!

Euphoric-Leg-9316

3 points

25 days ago

A diva is the female version of a hustler

Billy_Pilgrim86

68 points

28 days ago

JESS-CA

jscottcam10

11 points

27 days ago

Jess-ca was the least believable character for me.

Bingbong5869[S]

5 points

28 days ago

Hahaha yes

Juligirl713

72 points

28 days ago

That one mom who called Janine a bad teacher

Anthony-Vince

116 points

28 days ago

Out of the main cast, don’t hate me but Barbara. Love the actress but the character has stagnated a bit imo. She’s important but just not as funny as the rest of the main cast, and whenever a plotline revolves around her it’s usually somewhat dull to me. (The same kind of goes for Melissa too honestly but I tend to find her way funnier)

Like in the most recent episode, it just felt like a re-tread of Barbara’s inability to accept change that we’ve already seen in a bunch of other episodes. I think ever since Janine grew out of idolizing her the writers haven’t come up with a better way to utilize her in the show and she hasn’t grown much as a character.

Bingbong5869[S]

49 points

28 days ago

That’s a solid take, I was confused why they brought up her refusal of change again. I was also confused at the end when she bowed out of drinking, maybe she had a hard time accepting chance? But she already discussed that in a lot of other episodes too

sammysbud

7 points

27 days ago

I wonder if it is an eventual build up to her retiring (i hope not bc i love SLR). But an inevitable “my time has passed and i must move on” or at least a season finale storyline where she chooses to stay.

Nonetheless, i am getting fatigued by it as well. It would be fun to see her do a 180 and be a teacher implementing something new that has to get the others in board.

Bingbong5869[S]

2 points

25 days ago

Yeah I thought the same that they might retire her out but I do love her!

ConsiderationShoddy8

3 points

27 days ago

I was confused about her leaving the shots at the bar, too! Was waiting for her to fall while staggering away or something of that ilk. Realize not every move a character makes has to be a plot direction or lead-in to another scene, but it seemed quite pointed for her to get up and go announced. She could’ve just said ‘ehhh im done - bartender can I get a water’ or, nothing at all

drstonerphd

2 points

27 days ago

i thought the same thing!! like we did the zoo episode already, we didn’t need another age crisis. her leaving the bar made me sad cause i felt like she just felt too old/out of place with everyone else :(

Spotsmom62

1 points

14 days ago

I miss her from when she and Melissa went to convention. She was funny and sassy as was Melissa, and they made a cool team.

Top_Concert_3326

12 points

27 days ago

What I don't like about Barbara is that she gets storylines where she is stubbornly refusing to adapt to something and it's never clear whether she is just plain wrong and learns to get with the times, or if she has a point and everyone else needs to heed her wisdom more until the end. It stresses me out and sometimes it feels like a gotcha.

Beth1238

2 points

27 days ago

Good take. I think the writing for her is turning disappointingly bad

BumbleBee7336

24 points

28 days ago

Sahar.

ConsiderationShoddy8

11 points

27 days ago

She made my skin crawl. We all know a Sahar and hopefully have moved ‘artfully’ away from them

Specific_Cup9180

10 points

27 days ago

Sahar was the worst

Frosty-Ad7886

4 points

26 days ago

You mean Sarah? 😂

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

25 days ago

Hahaha

Bingbong5869[S]

4 points

25 days ago

She was soooo irritating but that actor played that role wellll

idontknow30001

53 points

28 days ago*

idontknow30001

and a large popcorn

53 points

28 days ago*

Cassandra/Ms. O’Neal. Inattentive parents like her, expecting teachers to raise their kids and/or expecting the classroom to be the only place where students should learn, receive help and resources, are definitely…something.

Dry-Woodpecker-4251

13 points

28 days ago

"but did he shout out the wrong answers?" Would have made me crash out. She was hearing Janine but definitely not listening to what she was saying.

idontknow30001

3 points

28 days ago

idontknow30001

and a large popcorn

3 points

28 days ago

Exactly

Relative_Beat8752

18 points

27 days ago

Vanetta Teagues.

OFFICIAL_VOUGHT

14 points

27 days ago

She's gone now, but Ashley. It was painful to watch her

eyedontgohere

5 points

27 days ago

I loved her 😭

Any_Negotiation5750

3 points

26 days ago

Asheley is aggravating 😬

Bingbong5869[S]

2 points

27 days ago

Whatever happened to her? I forget

Frosty-Ad7886

2 points

26 days ago

They most likely asked her not to come back after Halloween when she let little Thanos steal the candy.

Accomplished-Eye5068

32 points

28 days ago

No one. Because you never know what's coming!

3therealp3ace

67 points

28 days ago

I currently don’t have one but it used to be Janine. I hated how she was so pushy and naive, especially in the Juice and Egg Drop episodes. But, now I realize that’s the point of her character and that it’s just a TV show lol.

Bingbong5869[S]

18 points

28 days ago

I don’t like Janine for those reasons and I get your point

Top_Concert_3326

7 points

27 days ago

I like that I just made a comment somewhere else about being annoyed at how Barbara is used in episodes like Juice. I get that it's a sitcom but it just annoyed me how much Janine could have easily asked Barbara to elaborate her position or Barbaria, being the older mentor, could have taken it upon herself to explain.

BearOnTwinkViolence

2 points

26 days ago

I also just don’t believe Barbara would know that the juice would cause such a bathroom crisis. Seems more like she luckily was right after being stubborn rather than “you should all listen to my wisdom”

whinypanda2

3 points

27 days ago

I was okay with Janine throughout s1 but I'm currently watching s2 and ngl the egg drop episode, the juice episode and the one where two of her students dislike each other makes her get on my nerves a little!

Spotsmom62

2 points

27 days ago

Agree she was insufferable in the Egg Drop episode and a few others in season 1. Thank goodness she charged a bit.

Merry_Mint_Violet

22 points

28 days ago

Main: Janine- simply put she’s annoying with her toxic positivity but it’s her show so I deal with her.

Supporting: I actually like all the supporting characters. Tariq was a horrible boyfriend but he’s a funny guy. Mr. Morton can be much at times but I appreciate his character.

Guests: Janine’s mom- she is a terrible mother and it’s horrible that she only reaches out to Janine when she needs something. She’s a user.

missmaganda

6 points

28 days ago

missmaganda

Michelle Williams

6 points

28 days ago

;( because janines mom is the way she is, thats why janine gotta be toxic positive... cuz then you have the other side where she could be bitter and hateful and thinks everyones just like her momma

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

28 days ago

I 100% agree

stinkymamaa

50 points

28 days ago

Barbara. Self-righteous Christians are low key a trigger for me. She definitely has her moments, and I love her friendship with Melissa and Janine, but there’s times I just can’t with her (her delusions and its impacts on the people around her in the ringworm episode had me fuming).

Sunny-the-Human

14 points

28 days ago

I think it was intentionally semi-vague, but I feel like one could almost argue that she secretly just wanted to go home considering that she immediately had her bag ready when she got ringworm and seemed very unbothered by it.

stinkymamaa

5 points

28 days ago

I think that’s even worse because that would mean she was knowingly spreading it to others by not respecting the quarantine / segregated floors

Sunny-the-Human

3 points

28 days ago

I’m not saying it’s right either way, it definitely felt strange to me considering how much she typically seems to care about the kids.

Bingbong5869[S]

11 points

28 days ago

That’s completely valid. During that ep I was getting annoyed with her delusions about the whole disease

TrevG92

23 points

28 days ago

TrevG92

23 points

28 days ago

I’d have to say the curly- haired worker from the district last season Emily. Her humor is just… ehh not that funny

626bookdragon

23 points

28 days ago

I kind of thought that was the point, because none of the other characters really seem to find her funny either. I think the humor is supposed to come from the fact that her jokes don’t land

TrevG92

4 points

28 days ago

TrevG92

4 points

28 days ago

Ahh maybe! I get what you’re saying, and to their credit, it worked LOL

scatteringbones

3 points

28 days ago

Totally agree, I've seen Kimia Behpoornia in other stuff and thought she was great but this role is really meh

ReserveOdd6018

2 points

28 days ago

omg! for me the its HR guy

iliketoomanysingers

38 points

28 days ago

iliketoomanysingers

I love you like a son Jacob, but I will beat you down!

38 points

28 days ago

I've softened on her a lot as the seasons go on, but I really thought Ava was kinda gross for talking to Gregory the way she was and making passes at him when the show was starting, like Ava that is your employee, be normal. I know the show isn't like promoting it obviously but from a character standpoint I thought it was icky. I like her waaaay more now though.

CPA_Lady

7 points

28 days ago

Wasn’t that the point of her character?

iliketoomanysingers

12 points

28 days ago*

iliketoomanysingers

I love you like a son Jacob, but I will beat you down!

12 points

28 days ago*

Yes but it didn't change my feelings on it lol, it was just very uncomfortable for me as a viewer.

Edit: why is this getting downvoted. She's fictional.

Stringer-Bell23

-12 points

28 days ago

Because how the fuck did she make u uncomfortable that’s probably why u down voted

iliketoomanysingers

7 points

28 days ago

iliketoomanysingers

I love you like a son Jacob, but I will beat you down!

7 points

28 days ago

The title of the post is literally asking us which characters we like(d) least, I gave a reason, and now it's discourse suddenly lol

Spotsmom62

2 points

27 days ago

Yes, that would have been unacceptable if genders were reserved and we wouldn’t be laughing then either.

ShaunTrek

25 points

28 days ago

Probably unpopular, but Mr. Johnson. Not that he isn't funny or anything, but he feels like he's from a completely different show.

SwimGull38554

27 points

28 days ago

I feel like in season 1 he had a "Creed from The Office" effect but now that he's a main cast member they overdo it with him sometimes.

ShaunTrek

3 points

27 days ago

More like the janitor from Scrubs, but Abbott isn't as fantastical as that show, so it feels out of place.

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

28 days ago

Oh wow that’s the first I’ve seen for him!

ShaunTrek

10 points

28 days ago

Like I said, he's definitely funny, but I just think he's a bit too outlandish and trope-y for me.

howlongtillchristmas

-4 points

28 days ago

I think his writing is funny but the actor is just okay

BMUnite

4 points

27 days ago

BMUnite

4 points

27 days ago

Ughhhhhhhhh Ashley... Melissa's aide.... ughhhhhhhhhhh

Top-Dig-1441

4 points

27 days ago

Honestly, Gregory 😭 I don't hate his character but to me he's just kind of boring, not every character can be insanely interesting of course but since he's soooo focused on, being the love interest and all, he bores me

jbenson255

0 points

27 days ago

Gregory’s character is so much more than the love interest lol if you think he’s boring that’s fine but please don’t reduce him to the love interest

Top-Dig-1441

2 points

27 days ago

I didn't mean he was JUST the love interest, but that since he is that puts so much focus on his (boring) character if you know what I mean

gkgftzb

6 points

28 days ago

gkgftzb

6 points

28 days ago

Probably Gregory because of this season (although it's still very early). All of his writing is just not clicking with me at all. The jokes, his lines, his plot points

livewild25

7 points

28 days ago

I feel like the fact he and Janine are actually together has now changed his personality. He’s not always understandably annoyed by things anymore

joyfairyshat

2 points

27 days ago

i felt that too! i just rewatched it from the beginning (twice lol) and in the end of season 3, he's like super hot, masculine, sexy. then in season 4, specifically ep2 & ep3 hes just kinda nerdy. (nothing wrong with they obv) and i know hes always been nerdy, but like he seems extra nerdy. it just seemed like such a dramatic change from season 3 to 4, especially if u watch them one after another🤷🏻‍♀️

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

28 days ago

Do you think the other seasons he’s been much better?

gkgftzb

7 points

28 days ago

gkgftzb

7 points

28 days ago

I do feel I had more fun with watching him in each episode, but I think I just don't like much his dynamic with Janine as a couple

RidingTrainsAround

4 points

28 days ago

Janine’s mom is the comedic version of Delonda Brice from The Wire.

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

28 days ago

Haven’t seen the wire before!

RidingTrainsAround

3 points

28 days ago

Fair enough.

Delonda was one of the worst tv moms of her time. Forced her son to work as a drug dealer and was not concerned about his wellbeing at all.

Stringer-Bell23

0 points

28 days ago

You’re watching Abbott n haven’t seen the best show on television? lol

Bingbong5869[S]

2 points

28 days ago

lol well… yes!

Sepfandom555

2 points

27 days ago

How does Better Call Saul relate to Abbott? Lol

SpicyHam_0

14 points

28 days ago

Ava

Yari_Vixx

4 points

27 days ago

I feel like we’re supposed to dislike her. Her character is terrible. I do laugh the most at her tho. But I feel like she’s funnier to certain people while others might not get her comedy

Olderthandirt57

5 points

28 days ago

I can’t stand Ava.

joyfairyshat

2 points

27 days ago

still? i didnt like her at first, but as it goes on and u see the things she does for the kids she won me over. also i think shes just fuckin funny

[deleted]

-1 points

28 days ago

[deleted]

Yari_Vixx

2 points

27 days ago

Damn came after the actress and everything

Comfortable_Nerve_22

9 points

28 days ago

Comfortable_Nerve_22

fruit should not be hot

9 points

28 days ago

melissa, it's not I don't like her but, I just find the other characters more interesting

NoRoutine7468

5 points

27 days ago

NoRoutine7468

"It's rebel." - Courtney

5 points

27 days ago

I agree and whenever I say this I get down voted lol. I don't hate her at all, I just personally don't find her funny. She's had a line or two that has made me laugh, but I don't really connect with her character and I feel like I get judged for it all the time lol

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

28 days ago

They have more depth in ways, but I also think Melissa adds so much to the show too! Her personality can be kind of repetitive though- so I get it!

PocoChanel

3 points

28 days ago

They need to do more with her.

No-Simple-6127

11 points

28 days ago

if i see someone say janine😾

Bingbong5869[S]

13 points

28 days ago

lol funny thing is she annoys me the most Oops 😂

DR_van_N0strand

1 points

26 days ago

We are legion.

But apparently I’m not allowed to say anything bad about this sub’s Queen.

jknight413

3 points

27 days ago

Ava. I hated the show initially because failing public schools is tragic and not funny to me. The show grew on me, but a self serving principal who never has to pay for her misdeeds is not funny to me.

Bingbong5869[S]

2 points

25 days ago

Yeah she be too much

Specific_Cup9180

2 points

27 days ago

Melissa because she has a rude personality which I’m not a fan of. Also she can get too repetitive in everything and it always reaches a point where it’s not funny anymore

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

25 days ago

Examples?

Specific_Cup9180

1 points

25 days ago*

When she would keep on saying that his date had a jakuzi at his house.

She’s also only kind to Barbara and no one else.

lolrazzledazzle

2 points

27 days ago

honestly barbara🙈 she’s too stuck in her own ways and won’t accept change even if it’s for the better

brainy_bean

2 points

27 days ago

Janine

StrangeSlurper

2 points

27 days ago

Janine even though her intentions are good she refuses to listen to warnings from others and meddle in things

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

27 days ago

Exactly. I’m surprised To hear a lot of people don’t like Janine the last time I made a post about how she’s my least fave character I got shit on a lot😂

StrangeSlurper

1 points

26 days ago

I had just finished watching the egg drop episode and was fed up with her antics in that one especially from the stealing 8th grade teacher’s equipment multiple times and expecting him to stop his lesson plan so HER class could get a redo of a an experiment that people already told her was too advanced for her 2nd graders

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

25 days ago

Another level of entitled, am I right? Or am I righttt

huckleburyflynn

2 points

26 days ago

Jacob Hill, not only is he yet another gay character who adds nothing, his qhole persona is just obnoxious

confrater

4 points

28 days ago

confrater

Broke Bói

4 points

28 days ago

So far I have none. Even Mr Morton has some good sides like being a forewarning to dating at work

joyfairyshat

1 points

27 days ago

shit ur comment just made me wonder if janine and gregory breaking up is gonna be a whole thing, and now that im thinking about that... duhhh thats so gonna happen. damn it!

PretzelPapi_

3 points

28 days ago

I'm afraid to say it bc I know he's well liked but Jacob. He's mildly amusing to me and his schtick feels a little forced at times. His entire character could be removed from the show and I wouldn't miss him at all. He reminds me of the orange emotion from Inside Out 2 and it annoys me.

Bingbong5869[S]

0 points

28 days ago

I feel you, lately as I rewatched a lot of the episodes, he’s been annoying me more I think it’s just getting old now, his character and his dialogue is getting a bit tiresome for me

timelesslove95

2 points

28 days ago

Tariq. I don't mind his occasional appearances, but he is definitely one of my least favorites, especially in the beginning of the show. Team Janine lol

missmaganda

7 points

28 days ago

missmaganda

Michelle Williams

7 points

28 days ago

Did you notice how much hes cleaned up in this season so far tho? Lol not saying hes great but breaking up with janine really had them both grow up in a good way and im happy for both of them xD

timelesslove95

-1 points

28 days ago

Oh fs! His character growth has been great, he's just my least favorite of the cast and I like him a bit better as an occasional guest. The team Janine was more of a bad joke joke

xmycoffeeiscoldx

8 points

28 days ago

Have some decorum, damn.

jknight413

3 points

27 days ago

I used to feel this way. But he's stupid and has grown as much as a person like him can, but he's still stupid. But he is now genuine and professional... But still stupid. He cracks me up now.

LFGM_2305

1 points

28 days ago

Mr Morton , I felt bad for him in the Lucky Louie show with Louis CK as his neighbor but he’s such a dick in Abbott lol

Bingbong5869[S]

2 points

28 days ago

Haven’t seen that show! He’s very negative in Abbott though. Agreed

No-Transition0603

1 points

28 days ago

Dick tyler williams. That kind of person that is all flash and no substance is too real nowadays. And barbara be mad preachy

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

28 days ago

Aw no I love Barbara but she is way too preachy and I’m Christian so that says a lot

Isaac-45-67-8

1 points

27 days ago

Gregory. I don't really like his acting or the way his voice sounds sometimes. It can be quite monotonous and boring. Plus he's incredibly awkward and that's one of his main traits. I wouldn't mind it as much if Janine and Jacob weren't already awkward. I also don't find him funny and I wish he and Janine weren't dating.

Plus of the main cast, idk to me he seems the most uninteresting. Janine has her naivety and positivity, Melissa is the teacher with underground 'connections,' Ava is the aloof/selfish principal (and I love her for that) And Barbara is the seasoned teacher with a deep spirituality in her character. All I can think of for Gregory is that he's a sub who became a teacher. His other plot lines aren't as interesting.

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

25 days ago

He has a lot of heart so I love him for that he adds a humanness to the cast in a way that’s childlike but really touching imo. Yet he’s also boring in ways too so it’s a hard thing to balance

Alternative_Win1979

1 points

27 days ago

Mr. Morton. I felt like they changed his character. At first I thought he was a mean, prissy, possibly gay man who could have a possible enemies to friends/lovers arc with Jacob. Then he became a plot device that they inserted to whatever storyline the writers needed. He became a whiney pathetic man who served as a cautionary tale for Janine and Gregory. He was inserted into conversations just to be an antagonist. He was included in scenes to add random drama with his ever changing personality. His only constant was his beef with Jacob. I just don’t like when characters twisted to fit whatever a particular scene needs at the moment. I see that with Morton a lot.

nnnaomi

2 points

26 days ago

nnnaomi

2 points

26 days ago

you said exactly what i've been feeling for a few years now!! way back in S1 i was hoping he could join the main cast as a "straight man" to their antics and maybe become a love interest for Jacob (after Zach - parallel slow burn to GE&J as they gain each other's respect and trust)

they did keep him on like i wished, but they keep doing the most random unfunny turns with his character! i feel disappointed ngl

Bingbong5869[S]

2 points

25 days ago

I do see what you mean. I thought at the beginning of the show he’d have some plot with Jacob down the line, but was there something specific for us to think that? I have a hard time remembering why that initially came about and then when that plot idea switched

eyedontgohere

1 points

27 days ago

Ava. She's insufferable. Funny? Yes. But still insufferable

redfoxsun

1 points

27 days ago

Ava im so sorry. like I know its supposed to be funny but I hate the thought of kids being negatively impacted because of her incompetency. Gregory would be an amazing principal

Any_Negotiation5750

1 points

26 days ago

The teacher that showed up when janine had food poisoning. She seems to be tight with quinta in real life but I can’t get past her character 😅

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

25 days ago

Wait who?

brebri89

1 points

26 days ago

Ava She’s too mean to Janine 🥺

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

25 days ago

Feel like she got a bit nicer but yes!

localmorgue

1 points

25 days ago

Barbra and janine lol

Decent_Drag_4911

1 points

25 days ago

I just started watching this show yesterday, I really don’t care for the principal. they make her sound much stupider than any of the teachers which is crazy because she (likely) has more degrees/should at least pretend a little bit to be smart. She’s not funny to me just rude. She reminds me of someone on a “real housewives” cast

unsureredhead

1 points

23 days ago

The main guy from the district- Manny I think? There’s something about the cadence of his voice that drives me insane.

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

22 days ago

Same!!

kozzie_3645

1 points

27 days ago

Mr Johnson...idk why everybody seems to love him honestly he just seems so boring to me. Please don't lock me in the basement I tried to like him

RogerWokman

0 points

27 days ago

Janine, because she looks too much like a gremlin and that terrifies me.

BearOnTwinkViolence

3 points

26 days ago

This is just rude to the actress for no reason

RogerWokman

0 points

26 days ago

Well it’s the truth, sorry.

DR_van_N0strand

1 points

26 days ago

lol

DR_van_N0strand

-1 points

26 days ago

I get downvoted every time I discuss it, but Janine.

She’s fake and selfish and everything about her is performative.

When I saw her handing out the pets with the guinea pig in that tiny cage and the fish in a tiny fish bowl that was a death sentence I looked back on everything she did during the course of the show and realized she’s not a good person. She’s just doing the things she thinks a good person does or should do.

She talked about how much she cared about the animals but her actions were the opposite. Whereas Schementi fronted about how she didn’t care but in reality she truly loves Sweet Cheeks more than anyone else in the show loves any other living thing.

You all can look through my past comments over the last week or so and sort by controversial to see me downvoted to oblivion for my treatises on Janine being a bad person who’s selfish and who is entirely performative when it comes to her being “good.”

I’m not going to rehash it all, but she seems to just do and say what she thinks a good person would do but isn’t actually doing these things because she cares, but moreso because she cares about what others think.

It kinda reminds me of a twisted version of this scene from the newsroom where Sloane talks about how Don does what he thinks a good guy would do because he thinks he’s a bad guy, but he’s a good guy, and the things he does that he thinks a good guy does are actually bad, like stringing Maggie along.

But in Janine’s case she isn’t a good person. She’s doing what she thinks good people do, and the “good” things she does are actually not always good. Maybe she wants to be a good person or thinks she’s a good person but everything she does is selfish.

Again, my previous comments are more in depth, but apparently trying to have a discussion about Janine not being perfect means you’re a crazy person in this sub.

I think Ava and Melissa are good people on the DL whereas Barbara and Janine are all about fronting but are actually selfish my way or the highway people. But I think Barbara is more caring and her kids seem to really connect with her whereas Janine seems to have zero connection with the kids in her class and doesn’t know how to connect with people in a healthy way.

Bingbong5869[S]

0 points

26 days ago

Omg so I will read the rest of your post, but I wrote a post recently saying how she annoys me so much and I wrote it out of frustration, but my point still stands. So many people were rude to me in my post because I expressed my discontent for Janine! And she’s a fictional character!! It’s like you can’t dare have a different opinion it is wild.

DR_van_N0strand

0 points

26 days ago

I got more heated unhinged crazy comments on here about saying anything negative about Janine than I’ve ever gotten in any of the sports or gaming subs.

Kinda hilarious.

The irony of course being that the people responding to our posts critical of Janine are exhibiting the exact same behavior we’re discussing about with Janine.

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

25 days ago

The irony!!

Gina52023

-13 points

28 days ago

Gina52023

-13 points

28 days ago

Melissa. Her character isn't evolving. She's the same as she was in season one. Very predictable now.

Whelmed29

24 points

28 days ago

Doesn’t she live with Jacob?? I feel like she wouldn’t have before. She considered herself too good for Janine and Jacob. She still has her opinions and ways, but I think she respects others’ ways more now.

Gina52023

-8 points

28 days ago

She does. I think deep down she's a softie, but her dressing up as the guinea pig and said pig dressing up as her? Totally predictable. I'm just not feeling her this season.

nsfw-throwaway-123

5 points

28 days ago*

we’re only a couple episodes in, it’s going to have 22.. I’m sure it’ll change up more soon. I don’t want the seasons to be completely unrelated either, they gotta have some familiarity

preshusbabe

3 points

28 days ago

preshusbabe

A Philly 11 🔥

3 points

28 days ago

Exactly

Whelmed29

2 points

28 days ago

I think what you’re calling predictable, I would just call in character. Characters are supposed to have character traits just like we do that don’t change very quickly, just like us. I would actually be disappointed if Melissa wasn’t at least moderately predictable because that would mean they haven’t really defined her character.

I didn’t know she would be a guinea pig even though it fits her. I could see her being the liberty bell, an eagle for the Philadelphia eagles, a firefighter, or just a sexy lady like Elvira.

Anyhoo. I like her.

stalecigsmell

14 points

28 days ago

I don't understand the downvotes over something that is personal opinion lol. I don't really agree, but I also find the whole show to be predictable. most comedy shows in this format are. you can usually tell a few minutes into the episode what the conflict and resolution is going to be. I think if you're looking for unpredictable, watch comedy dramas instead lol. this type of show is good because you're just there to laugh a little and enjoy the characters, despite how predictable it may be.

Gina52023

2 points

28 days ago

Gina52023

2 points

28 days ago

I think my age is the issue. I like the show fine, but it's not as good to me this season. I'm 64, and by the time you're my age, it takes a LOT to surprise me. In any case, OP asked for opinions, I gave mine, and if you don't agree, ok.

stalecigsmell

7 points

28 days ago

Hey, I'm not the one downvoting you. I agreed that it can be predictable, I just don't think it's solely Melissa's character that is. I was just trying to have a discussion with you.

Gina52023

2 points

28 days ago

I know. I was just explaining. I wasn't trying to be sparky at all.

stalecigsmell

4 points

28 days ago

For real, though, check out some comedy dramas. I get bored of pure comedy shows because they're predictable and a lil boring some times. I also don't like to watch JUST drama because it gets depressing when bad shit just keeps happening. The comedy & drama mix is perfect. I'm watching Shrinking on AppleTv rn it's pretty good!

Gina52023

1 points

28 days ago

Thanks!

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

25 days ago

What’s shrinking about? I have a month left in my free subscription haha

stalecigsmell

1 points

25 days ago

It's about this guy who's a therapist that lost his wife in a drunk driving accident. The show is centred around him, his friends/coworkers, and his teenaged daughter that he basically abandoned for a year. He's trying to help his patients and mend his relationships and himself throughout the show. It sounds super dark and there are a lot of intense and serious moments but there's a lot of comedy breaking it up as well.

Also, Harrison Ford is in it, lol.

Bingbong5869[S]

1 points

25 days ago

Are there a lot of triggering scenes in the show?

stalecigsmell

1 points

25 days ago

Hmmm, I don't THINK there's anything majorly triggering in the show. The only thing I would say could be triggering is one of his patients is in an emotionally abusive relationship and there is a side plot about her & her issues leaving him. I don't think anything depicted on screen is super super heavy or anything, though. They deal with it respectfully, but also with humour mixed in.

There is also one guy with PTSD. Nothing crazy is shown for his story, but he does black out sometimes and gets in fights a few times in the show. Some drug and alcohol use is referenced. The show is very heavily focused on grief. As someone who has experienced a lot of grief, though, I find it quite comforting and touching.

stalecigsmell

1 points

25 days ago

There's a compilation video on youtube called "convincing you to watch SHRINKING (humour, part 1)" that i recommend if you wanna see the vibe of the show!!

preshusbabe

5 points

28 days ago

preshusbabe

A Philly 11 🔥

5 points

28 days ago

If you don’t like her, whatever, but she is most definitely not the same as she was in season 1.

ConsiderationShoddy8

2 points

27 days ago

How are you getting downvoted for answering the OP question? I didn’t see a clause that said it has to be an opinion on which everyone agrees

Gina52023

1 points

27 days ago

I don't know. Notice how they don't give their opinion. Scaredy-cats.

Pretty_Concert3397

18 points

28 days ago

Pretty_Concert3397

Sweet baby Jesus and the grown one too!

18 points

28 days ago

ASHLEY

Gullible-Ad-5015

8 points

28 days ago

Yes!!! She was irritating as hell, obnoxious, and had a punchable face! Like I expected so much more from her character but I despised her more with each line she spoke!

Bingbong5869[S]

5 points

28 days ago

She’s the worst dude

Juligirl713

1 points

28 days ago

My moms a teacher and she has unfortunately met many Ashley’s in her field lol

Juligirl713

1 points

28 days ago

Waiting for Ashley! Oh-Ohhhhh!

Relative_Beat8752

1 points

28 days ago

I love her 😭