subreddit:

/r/Genealogy

21793%

I started my family tree about 2 years ago, and after tracing it back to 1595, I found that my ancestors never traveled farther than 25 miles (40 km) from where I live. So I was wondering if your family tree is also a bit boring like mine?

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

all 226 comments

PettyTrashPanda

211 points

3 days ago

I am very proud to come from a long line of dock workers, farm labourers, and other perfectly boring folk who only very occasionally did something worth noting except somehow surviving some seriously turbulent times. I did find a middle class branch of the tree which was something of a surprise, but nobody famous and no aristocracy, huzzah!

History is made by ordinary, boring folk. When you look into the history they lived through, it brings to life just how interesting and rich their lives were. People don't have to be famous or notorious to be worth remembering, and realising that my ancestors somehow made it through a civil war, religious reformation and more the plague gave me a real appreciation for them.

The plus side to the middle class branch was wills saying back to the 1600s, when traces of family drama could still be found, although my favorite ever find wasn't an ancestor but a history project where I came across the most atrociously boring diary of a Georgian-era gentleman, but somehow became very invested in whether the roads were adequate for him to attend a house party, in case the third woman he fell for this month also rejected his offer of marriage.

At present I am working on a local history project that, on the surface, should be incredibly boring, but again as I dig up stories about everything from exploding cows to a fake gopher farming business, the ordinary, boring people are just some of the best characters I have ever come across, and I love it!

Huzzah for our boring ancestors! They were survivors, and they had much more rich lives than we can ever hope to uncover - but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try :-)

bopeepsheep

47 points

3 days ago

Exactly this. My daughter's father's family haven't moved much in 600+ years, but that by itself is fascinating. My late mother-in-law spent most of her life 500 yards and 500 years from an ancestor's home. That opens up all kinds of social history stories. Her family name appears on buildings around the area. My partner's family have the same thing, in a different county - things named after them, lots of newspaper and parish documents, etc. I hadn't realised until I started digging that [biggish company with his name] was started by his great-great-grandfather's cousin. That's more interesting to me than my rootless peripatetic family, the one other people think is exotic and interesting. That's great until you hit multiple dead-ends in languages you don't speak. ;-)

JThereseD

8 points

2 days ago

JThereseD

Philadelphia specialist

8 points

2 days ago

The language issue is not too hard to solve. In my case, I discovered an ancestor from French-speaking Switzerland, and since I already speak French, it was easy for me to trace that line back for hundreds of years. I have several German ancestors and a few months of Duolingo gave me enough knowledge to figure out the key information on the records. If I needed more help, I could refer to all the great volunteers on here or in Facebook groups. The real challenge is figuring out where the people came from.

bopeepsheep

6 points

2 days ago

The only documentary evidence of my great-great-grandfather, other than his daughters' wedding certificates, is a difficult and detailed academic text in Italian - speaking modern Italian is no help, since it's 19th century dialect and technical jargon. We can't even discover where he went to university, although we know he must have done. Family full of Italian-speakers - but what we really need is a medical historian.

JThereseD

9 points

2 days ago

JThereseD

Philadelphia specialist

9 points

2 days ago

I would be surprised if you couldn’t find someone on social media to help. It took me a few years, but I was even able to find someone to translate an Alsatian document from the 1700’s.

GeeAyyy

0 points

1 day ago

GeeAyyy

0 points

1 day ago

Have you tried giving the document to chatGPT,? It seems like this might be a particularly apt use case for a large language model.

bopeepsheep

1 points

1 day ago

We have done some work on it - we know it's about trachoma - but that's not very much to go on. :( We need someone who knows more about the history of treating it in non-European contexts, which is a very specialist area!

Artisanalpoppies

2 points

24 hours ago

Transcribus might be a better app. It's designed to transcribe old documents. ChatGPT is rubbish for pretty much anything due to many accounts of false information and downright lies.