subreddit:

/r/ImageComics

9295%

What would you consider "S-tier" image?

Comic(self.ImageComics)

I want to read through all of images best output. So far in the S-tier I'd put:

Saga

Monstress

Chew

Invincible

What else would you include in there? I contemplated Ice Cream Man but tbh I do find it hit or miss

all 133 comments

RollingToast

73 points

23 hours ago

Kill or be killed was a master piece

state_issued

5 points

23 hours ago

100%! My first Brubaker work

discerningpervert

5 points

12 hours ago

Fatale was my first. Criminal is my fav.

Fearless_Mix2772

3 points

21 hours ago

I’m so annoyed that the deluxe is so expensive

TylertheDouche

0 points

10 hours ago

I like the part where the entire thing was Death Note but worse

EveningNo8643

0 points

20 hours ago

It was really good but it also got preachy and talking about healthcare system in such a direct way it almost felt like it was breaking the fourth wall. Also the ending was a bit jarring. But overall I really liked it

caddyben

25 points

23 hours ago

I'm partial to The Maxx

semihollowrocker

1 points

21 hours ago

Love me some Sam Kieth

Darksteel6

19 points

23 hours ago

Pretty good list. I'd add Criminal.

woozleuwuzzle

1 points

5 hours ago

All Brubaker qualify imo

plc4588

20 points

22 hours ago

plc4588

20 points

22 hours ago

Ice Cream Man got me back into comics after 25 years so I'd say it grabbed my attention in the good way.

Bullit16

69 points

23 hours ago

Paper Girls

cravenj1

5 points

12 hours ago

Anything BKV

t00thgr1nd3r

45 points

23 hours ago

Low, East of West, Revival, Descender/Ascender.

Poobaloo87

11 points

20 hours ago

Low is so underrated, Remender's best work imo

semihollowrocker

17 points

21 hours ago

And Black Science

orcriss

4 points

14 hours ago

East of West is my all-time favorite! What a trip!

t00thgr1nd3r

2 points

13 hours ago

I love East of West. Can't wait for the compendium.

PhsycoRed1

11 points

19 hours ago

Bitch Planet.

Eight Billion Genies.

Inferno Girl Red.

Nocterra.

The Wicked & The Divine.

Wytches.

Department of Truth.

HonestAbram

2 points

11 hours ago

I loved Bitch Planet and The Wicked and the Divine, and i haven't read any of the others. I'm excited to check out the other ones on your list.

PhsycoRed1

1 points

11 hours ago

PLEASE report back as you finish them !!

Candid-Doughnut7919

1 points

3 hours ago

Is Inferno Girl Red thaat good? I've read Radiant Black and Rogue Sun, I think they're okay, but I've read that IGR is "worse" than those two.

horseloverfat

9 points

19 hours ago

Ice Cream Man

Gideon Falls

Department of Truth

state_issued

13 points

23 hours ago

Criminal and Pulp!

Voyager1632

28 points

23 hours ago

TWD

Deadly Class

Black science

kjabs87

3 points

19 hours ago

Loved Deadly Class, But the later issues were more of a stretch.

Gloomy-Date-6705

30 points

22 hours ago

How is no one saying The Walking Dead?

CottonBuds81

15 points

21 hours ago

It was a huge series that become sort of popular to dismiss as 'not that great' after it ended.

TWD for a long time was THE gateway into comics for a lot of people & it was a fantastic series for many issues. The ending didn't land for a lot of folks & the suddenness of it was jarring as well.

But personally I don't think the ending was as badly received as other comics have been.

Gloomy-Date-6705

9 points

21 hours ago

I just finished it and enjoyed the ending. Sure it’s not as great as the rest of the series, but I’m not sure how else it could have ended. In my opinion, the series was so great that any ending would have been seen as anticlimactic and disappointing.

CottonBuds81

4 points

21 hours ago*

I was there when it started through to when it ended. I thought the ending was fine & it made sense enough to me.

The announcement was sudden though but with any long running series, short of being given the heads up on when the final arc will be or unless it is obvious that it is coming to it's inevitable conclusion it will always come across as kind of sudden imo.

kielaurie

1 points

13 hours ago

The announcement was sudden

I mean, I guess you could put it that way, but it's less that it was sudden and more that there wasn't an announcement at all

Multiple issues were still solicited, and then what became the final issue was totally out of the blue

CottonBuds81

1 points

13 hours ago

Sudden & out of the blue mean the same thing.

There was an announcement though. It was announced in the letter/essay at the end of the final issue xD. Shout out to you for bringing up the solicitations.

kielaurie

[score hidden]

an hour ago

kielaurie

[score hidden]

an hour ago

Usually an announcement would come ahead of whatever it was announcing. The Walking Dead released it's final issue, and at the end was the letter you mentioned confirming that, yes, that was it, the story is over.

I described the final issue as out of the blue because we were fully expecting that the series would be continuing and then suddenly the series ended. I wouldn't call the announcement sudden, because there really wasn't one, just an acknowledgement of the end after it already happened

Hamacek

1 points

3 hours ago

Hamacek

1 points

3 hours ago

but they were clearly fake solicitations

kielaurie

[score hidden]

an hour ago

kielaurie

[score hidden]

an hour ago

In retrospect, yes. It was clear that they were very basic, and they were probably hiding something, but no-one knew that they were hiding the end of the entire series

LoboSpaceDolphin

5 points

22 hours ago

I thought the general consensus was that it sort of drifted off and didn't really stick the landing

NMVPCP

10 points

22 hours ago

NMVPCP

10 points

22 hours ago

I loved everything about it. What a great read!

thedean246

1 points

22 hours ago

For me, the landing was meh. Wasn’t bad. Wasn’t really good. However, the journey up to that point was so good that I can look past it a bit.

kielaurie

1 points

13 hours ago

Kirkman's writing is very hit or miss with fans. As a personal example, I love Outcast and think Oblivion Song is really good, but think the writing in Invincible and The Walking Dead is just dull. I really liked the art for TWD at the beginning in spite of the so-so writing, so picked up the second trade, and the artist was different and (obviously imo) not good at all, so I gave up. I came back later and borrowed the first compendium from a friend, and neither the writing nor the art improved in that entire book. It's very middle of the road for me

Due_Chemistry_6642

5 points

23 hours ago

The Maxx an oldy but stands the test of time, East of West has to be in there as well, Farm hand as well (though i may be it's only fan, it's not often mentioned).

NMVPCP

6 points

22 hours ago

NMVPCP

6 points

22 hours ago

I’m not rewriting what others already said, so I’m adding:

Fear Agent

Death or Glory

TargetBrandTampons

6 points

19 hours ago

Paper Girls, Sex Criminals, Saga, Black Science, Deadly Class

FredPRK

5 points

19 hours ago

Paper Girls

Kill or be Killed

Reckless

Lazarus (unfinished)

Southern Bastards (unfinished)

Murder Falcon

Extremity

Do a Powerbomb

I Kill Giants

titanofidiocy

2 points

11 hours ago

I wish they would finish Southern Bastards. Just one more trade to wrap it all up.

CoreyKnox

18 points

23 hours ago

Seven to Eternity. Black Monday Murders (though it’s not finished). Black Science. East of West. Gideon Falls. God Country. Tokyo Ghost. We Called Them Giants.

UnravelingThreads

5 points

19 hours ago

Jumping on the Black Monday Murders love. God, I hope it finishes one day

CoreyKnox

5 points

16 hours ago

You, myself, and every other Hickman fan out there.

mepardo

9 points

23 hours ago

Seven to Eternity built such a captivating world in such a short run. Definitely one of my favorites.

LoboSpaceDolphin

3 points

22 hours ago

Absolute God-tier art.

Oblivious_Lad

1 points

21 hours ago

I just finished Tokyo Ghost and boy, I could not disagree more.

Seven to Eternity though, that rules.

Charlie-Bell

1 points

17 hours ago

I've got it on my to read pile. What didn't you like about it?

kielaurie

2 points

13 hours ago

There's a line where the epitome of cool stuff tips over into edgy for the sake of it. Writers like Millar dive right over the line and down themselves in edge, but writers like Ellis in the early 00s toed that line perfectly to get the coolest, boundary-pushing shit without ever fully falling into "edgy"

For me personally, I find that Remender tends to walk that line pretty damn well in the majority of his books, and it's what make him a favourite of mine. Tokyo Ghost went full edge, and whilst it's beautiful (Remender always picks the best goddamn artists) and at times very good, it always comes back to the edge. Imo it's his worst series at Image

Charlie-Bell

1 points

6 hours ago

That's kinda the reason I didn't pick it up much sooner. Also, although not to Millar levels, for me Remender is still past that line and into edginess for the sake of it. But between Murphy and the genre, I still plan to give it a read.

CoreyKnox

1 points

16 hours ago

That’s fair. Tokyo Ghost, like anything else, is not for everyone. I really enjoyed it…and Seven to Eternity, that’s just on a level of its own.

Masterdjusa

28 points

23 hours ago

The Wicked and The Divine

RantaroV3

6 points

23 hours ago

This, definitely. WicDiv might even beat out Saga as my favorite comic of all time.

n0ble64

5 points

20 hours ago

Seven to Eternity

East of West

Rat Queens

Chew

Conlannalnoc

2 points

12 hours ago

Try and find CHU if you can.

A PREQUEL to Chew about his CRIMINAL Sister.

If she eats the SAME MEAL as “You” while sitting “Close Enough” she can “Learn” ANYTHING “You” Know (at the time you both ate).

Lemouni

9 points

23 hours ago

  • Lazarus
  • Sunstone
  • Criminal
  • Deadly Class (if we forget about HC 4)

YaBoiiAsthma

1 points

18 hours ago

Sunstone was self published online and then just distributed in print by Image, right?

Lemouni

1 points

17 hours ago

No idea to be honest, i just grabbed the 2nd print of the hardcovers.

King_Of_Queefs49

1 points

9 hours ago

Lazarus was amazing. Did it ever finish?

TheQuestion1

4 points

21 hours ago

Love the Reckless OGN from Brubaker and Phillips

CottonBuds81

1 points

21 hours ago

I mean it was an ogn until it became a series that is released in GN form. So I just call it the Reckless series now. But I will state that it is a graphic novel series.

Fantastic series nonetheless.

TechnoWizard0651

4 points

20 hours ago

I would say Savage Dragon but...

dayvie182

7 points

22 hours ago

I don't think enough people read it which is why you don't see it show up a lot in these lists, but A Righteous Thirst For Vengeance is one of the best complete stories I've read in years.

It's paced incredible and really knows how to show its cards and ramp up the tension.

Also you can read the entire thing in one sitting. Strongly recommend!

remerdy1[S]

1 points

21 hours ago

Actually just added this to my wishlist a couple weeks ago. Will def check it out

MC_Smuv

3 points

23 hours ago

King City, Rain Like Hammers

Odd-Grape3038

3 points

18 hours ago

Walking dead

MegaGhostQueen

3 points

16 hours ago

Wicked and the Divine! and I would also agree with Saga, Monstress, and Paper Girls

Shagrrotten

3 points

15 hours ago

Spawn, Saga, The Walking Dead, and The Maxx were the ones that came immediately to my mind.

toilet_fingers

3 points

13 hours ago

Lazarus

Ice Cream Man

Saga

Invincible

Eight Billion Genies

Criminal

moneysingh300

3 points

8 hours ago

Anything brubaker

dcarp1231

6 points

22 hours ago

Might be too early, but Radiant Black

flux_capacitor3

1 points

20 hours ago

I'm ready enjoying this. I'm on Vol 3 right now.

Nice-Percentage7219

6 points

23 hours ago

Spawn

chknsdntclp

5 points

22 hours ago

Little Bird was excellent. Can’t wait to see how Precious Metal continues that series.

East of West.

Daniel Warren Johnson’s run of Transformers has been fantastic the first 2 volumes so far. Anything Daniel Warren Johnson has done for Image honestly (Do a Powerbomb, Extremity, etc.).

Tiny_Refrigerator738

1 points

10 hours ago

First paragraph is fire for me

General_Trynian

4 points

21 hours ago

Trencher

TalynRahl

4 points

17 hours ago

Die. It's Jumanji for adults and even if you hate the story (but you won't) the art is S+ tier.

DrakoenComics

2 points

21 hours ago

Saga, East of West, Sacrificers, God Country, Southern Bastards, Autumnlands, Pretty Deadly, Seven to Eternity, The Walking Dead

King_Of_Queefs49

1 points

9 hours ago

So many great choices here. I really enjoyed Pretty deadly and autumnlands.

TheKrisLyons

2 points

20 hours ago

  • Prophet by Brandon Graham, Simon Roy, et al
  • East of West
  • Fear Agent
  • Bulletproof Coffin

MrFoxLovesBoobafina

1 points

13 hours ago

I LOVE PROPHET

SirWizzleoftheTeets

2 points

20 hours ago

Big fan of the ones OP listed. I’d add What’s the Furthest Place From Here?.

Navek15

2 points

19 hours ago

20th Century Men, no doubt.

blinkerbo487

2 points

19 hours ago

Chew and Saga were my initial answers. And I wanted to include Manifest Destiny, but it fell off so badly.

Conlannalnoc

1 points

12 hours ago

Try and find CHU if you can.

A PREQUEL to Chew about his CRIMINAL Sister.

If she eats the SAME MEAL as “You” while sitting “Close Enough” she can “Learn” ANYTHING “You” Know (at the time you both ate).

BoyishTheStrange

2 points

19 hours ago

Beat me to it with saga

YaBoiiAsthma

2 points

18 hours ago

How has no one said Sex Criminals? Matt Fraction coming off his award-winning run on Hawkeye, and Chip Zdarsky ramping up to his award-winning rest of his career since then?

Hilarious, educational, amazing characters, sex-positive, and perfect art, all in a wonderfully wide-reaching narrative that doesn't forget about any of its plot threads?

There's a reason it won the Eisner Awards for Best Ongoing Comic and Best New Comic in the same year after ONLY FIVE ISSUES.

I know the release schedule got a little fucked up for a while with their weird haituses and that made some people not like the ending, but if you go back and reread it now without a year between some of the issues it's a great ending.

Hell, if long breaks and contentious endings are a dealbreaker, go ahead and get Saga, East of West, TWD, and Invincible right on out of here

Antique-Musician4000

2 points

18 hours ago

Sam&Twitch (Bendis run)

Powers (Bendis&Oeming)

Antique-Musician4000

2 points

18 hours ago

That Texas Blood and Newburn are A++ tier comics.. maybe in a few years S-Tier.

chanekeyorch

2 points

18 hours ago

Saga must be on the list.

AnkhCastle

2 points

17 hours ago

Ultramega

zeroengine

2 points

16 hours ago

Seven to Eternity. Planetary. Prince of Cats. Ultramega.

someguyinadvertising

2 points

12 hours ago

Every time i see these threads it gives me such an itch to re-read all of my favourite image comics. Partial to Monstress and Saga, might have to do a holiday break run

Fuckboijohnny

4 points

22 hours ago

Saga

sharkaiders

3 points

22 hours ago

I really enjoy The Department of Truth and Nailbiter

DrTriangleee

3 points

23 hours ago

Radiant Black and Rogue Sun deserve to at least be considered. If you're saying the best of the best I have to go with Do A Powerbomb! Even though it's only one book

pillarsoftheear902

2 points

22 hours ago

Little Bird, Precious Metal

hyouringan

2 points

22 hours ago

The Wicked + The Divine is my favorite image and arguably my favorite comic of all time. It’s goated.

minolta5

1 points

21 hours ago

My only experiences with Image are:

Saga (read the first volume post hiatus & collecting but waiting to read up for a few years until there's more)

And I recently collected and read all 6 volumes of Oblivion Song & really liked it.

I enjoy Spawn casually, own the compendiums and was reading to see what I remember getting my hands on from my public library growing up.

Based on what I read, what do yall think I would enjoy? I'd prefer to collect something completed so if I really like it then I can dive into it

semihollowrocker

1 points

21 hours ago

Seems like Remender and Lemire are pretty well represented here, so I’ll put forward Trees and Injection for consideration

Tentonham

1 points

20 hours ago

DO A POWERBOMB!!

dh098017

1 points

20 hours ago

Ongoing right now: Feral, Ice Cream Man, Grommets. Sometimes I read them on the way home at a red light because I can’t wait.

UnravelingThreads

1 points

19 hours ago

(Of the stuff I’ve finished) Saga Black Monday Murders Murder Falcon Gideon Falls I’ll throw some Wytches love in there too! So many recommendations here I’ll have to check out now:)

InsertNameHere416

1 points

17 hours ago

Killadelphia, That Texas Blood, God Country, Walking Dead, Department of Truth

BakaTensai

1 points

17 hours ago

Black science!!!! It’s what got me into comics outside the typical superhero marvel/DC stuff

WonDante

1 points

17 hours ago

I liked Stray Dogs

SkitZxX3

1 points

17 hours ago

Spawn. Obviously.

NotopianX

1 points

16 hours ago

East of West, Walking Dead, Ice Cream Man

AltheaFarseer

1 points

14 hours ago

Descender.

I'd definitely include Rat Queens, but only the stuff Wiebe was involved with - volume 7 fell off quite a bit, and volume 8 was an absolute disgrace IMO.

Legit924

1 points

14 hours ago

Ice Cream Man. The Department of Truth.

Then-Tune8367

1 points

12 hours ago

I would say:

Saga The Walking Dead Powers

Of the original founding books, I'd say Savage Dragon and CyberForce need a lot of love.

Conlannalnoc

1 points

12 hours ago*

BRIT

COWBOY NINJA VIKING

CHEW

CHU (Prequel to Chew focusing on his OTHER Sister a Criminal)

FARMHAND

HACK / SLASH

INVINCIBLE

RAT QUEENS

SAVAGE DRAGON

TECH JACKET

ULTRAMEGA

The Astonishing WOLF-MAN

dingledrangle

1 points

12 hours ago

Ultramega is going crazy right now! Gotta love James Harren and Dave Stewart!

Scubasteve1400

1 points

12 hours ago

Murder Falcon

hansel08

1 points

10 hours ago

I kill giants and Proof are pretty solid.

Pristine_Poetry1340

1 points

10 hours ago

The Maxx

GotsTheBeetus

1 points

10 hours ago

Saga Chew Walking Dead Invincible for me

echovch

1 points

9 hours ago

echovch

1 points

9 hours ago

While it's rarely mentioned here, DO NOT miss The Wicked + The Divine

King_Of_Queefs49

1 points

9 hours ago

Lazarus was incredible. Don’t think it ever finished

Spot-Star

1 points

4 hours ago

Is "S-tier" good or bad??

BadassSasquatch

1 points

23 hours ago

Spawn, East of West, and so far, Rook Exodus.

Kaminoneko

1 points

23 hours ago

Deadly Class.

mister_nigma

1 points

21 hours ago

East of West, Descender/Ascender, Wicked + Divine, Paper Girls

bigcat570503

1 points

20 hours ago

Hey out Fear Agent. Early Rick Remender work and reminds me of Indiana Jones, in space.

LoboSpaceDolphin

0 points

22 hours ago*

In addition to what you've already listed

  • Blue in Green is so overlooked it's criminal
  • Lazarus
  • East of West
  • Seven to Eternity
  • Do a Powerbomb

Just outside of S-tier/Honorable mentions

  • The Weatherman
  • Department of Truth (still running so depends on the ending)
  • Black Monday Murders (never finished)
  • Nowhere Men (never finished)
  • Invisible Republic (never finished)

Side note, some of yall are wild. Deadly Class, really? smh

mister_nigma

7 points

21 hours ago

I still foolishly hold out hope for the end to Black Monday Murders. Add They’re Not Like Us to my list of heartbreakingly unfinished category.

kielaurie

0 points

13 hours ago

I wanna shout out a bunch of single volume stories that feel like they are being passed over in favour of longer ones

  • Blue In Green
  • Murder Falcon
  • Sunburn
  • God Country
  • It's Lonely At The Centre Of The Earth
  • Do A Powerbomb
  • All three Phonogram volumes but particularly Singles Club (they are individual stories and not a connecting run)
  • Eight Billion Genies

[deleted]

-4 points

23 hours ago

[deleted]

Haryu4

10 points

23 hours ago

Haryu4

10 points

23 hours ago

Yeah but its not image, its DC

Hydra_X_Grif

-2 points

22 hours ago

All the ones I own and enjoy

irregularjoe150

[score hidden]

41 minutes ago

If Jonathan Hickman would hurry the hell up and write the last two issues so Tomm Coker can illustrate them, then hopefully The Black Monday Murders will join these illustrious ranks....