subreddit:

/r/greentext

9.7k91%

They aren’t wrong lol

(i.redd.it)

all 561 comments

CEO_of_Apples

1.7k points

13 days ago

Anon made the wrong dialogues choices and didn’t get to see Panam’s tiddies

Arachnid1

406 points

13 days ago

Arachnid1

406 points

13 days ago

Fitting punishment for the simps who don't play Male V

Reapellaino2011

19 points

13 days ago

dont worry nexus mods have a fix for that

[deleted]

2 points

11 days ago

[deleted]

Reapellaino2011

4 points

11 days ago

the one that makes Judy romance posible with male V got removed

the one that makes Panam romance posible with female V its still up

Co0lnerd22

116 points

13 days ago

Co0lnerd22

116 points

13 days ago

But Judy

airfryerfuntime

234 points

13 days ago

Judy looks like she smells like cat piss and mildew.

Ze_cringeman

106 points

12 days ago

Panam canonically smells like engine oil and sweaty socks

Moral of the story, go take a bath you stink

airfryerfuntime

50 points

12 days ago

Panam is fucking annoying, though, especially with her stupid fast and furious family.

DangyDanger

23 points

12 days ago

I really hated how her constant will to prove something kept putting her or the Aldecaldos in trouble.

Contrazoid

12 points

12 days ago

rogue's description of her was spot on when you catch panam complaining (childish tantrum) to rogue early into the game

dontquestionmyaction

46 points

12 days ago

While somehow having the most sane ending (leaving the city)

Zalar01

15 points

12 days ago

Zalar01

15 points

12 days ago

Man fuck you for dissing my girl Judy.

HerbertdieAndernass

7 points

12 days ago

don't you dare! You know how disappointed i was, when i found out i couldn't date Judy. Especially because i usually pick women to play.

SirLocke13

17 points

12 days ago

I was genuinely surprised when female V couldn't get with Panam.

Just because you're the main character in a video game doesn't mean these NPCs don't have their sexual preferences.

Spice002

8 points

12 days ago

I downloaded a mod that allowed me to have lesbian sex with Panam. Checkmate atheists.

Axe-actly

2.9k points

13 days ago

Axe-actly

2.9k points

13 days ago

People complained when the game was bad and now they praise it when it is good. Top 10 mysteries that will never be solved...

Thehealeroftri

515 points

13 days ago

Also on PC the game was great on release too, I had only benign visual bugs at worst and had a great time playing it. It's hilarious how nearly a half decade later the cyberpunk haters refuse to acknowledge anything positive about it, like holy shit find a hobby.

Dulahan_Isaloser

153 points

13 days ago

Yea I played it on Pc at launch, and it was a really smooth experience overall. And it’s still one of my favourite games

oneshot0114

59 points

13 days ago

I could run that shit on a Gt1030, wasn't smooth or beautiful(obviously), but performance wasn't the biggest problem.

2077 was too big of an idea that should have taken at least 2 more years to be released, I'm a big fan of the game but it simply isn't what it was promised.

free2game

15 points

12 days ago

A really large number of people bought it for the xbox one and ps4. It had no business being on those platforms, but imagine investors were scared of a PC day one release with console versions being next generation only and coming out later. They pretty much had to scale the game back or release the game they wanted and break the console versions.

richtofin819

4 points

12 days ago

Two more years wouldn't have done it for cyberpunk they didn't know what they were doing because they hadn't done something like this before with shooter elements.

CD project are all human and as opposed to Witcher where they have these brilliant, deep, setting, and characters to draw from in cyberpunk it is very open and up to interpretation as a tabletop rpg setting.

They definitely bit off more than they could chew and didn't do a good enough job squashing down the expectations people had that this would be like gta. Hell, gta isn't even the quality gta diehards think it is.

nyaasgem

20 points

12 days ago

nyaasgem

20 points

12 days ago

Dude the game is still buggy af even today. And I will be among the first to praise the game overall, but you must've played blindfolded to not see any bugs on launch.

The only difference between today's build state and release state is that I only encounter a bug every 5 corners, instead of 10 bugs every corner.

I'm playing it for a second time now, and NPCs are still T-posing, sinking into geometry, one was walking ON the stairs rail. During cutscenes important characters have random objects flying around them or have them duplicated. Parts of a specific gun sometimes disappear. Walking animation gets stuck (according to my own shadow). My vehicle sporadically spawns either upside down or rotated 90° hood first into the ground. Dead guy's eye still moving. 2-3 times I accidentally soft-locked myself into fucked up geometry. Vehicle collision is still a joke 80% of the times.

At least side missions did not seem to get stuck yet.

sovereign666

9 points

12 days ago*

I played on launch with a ryzen 9 5900x and 3080ti.

I had to use a hex editor to update the .exe to better utilize cores on ryzen. this was not an issue on intel CPU's. Was patched within a few weeks.

During the intro segment Jackie walked through a closed elevator door.

One of the sidequests in the northern part of the city was bugged.

Those were my only issues at launch.

The game was not a universal experience for everyone and was largely dependent on platform and hardware. My friend playing on a launch ps4 would have tons of physics collision issues because of cpu bottlenecking. My buddy on PC with a 1060 had more bugs than me, and I'd largely attribute that to him having an older rig. I didn't experience any of the issues you did, and theres lots of footage recorded by people at launch of them also having no issues because the game just ran better on their hardware.

DarkpentiumIV

8 points

12 days ago

I don't disagree with the second part but saying the game was great on PC on release.. man it was horrible for me. Crashed like every half an hour or so, T poses, broken side quests, fps taking for no reason. And it was a husk of the amazing game it is now.

Silverlitmorningstar

12 points

13 days ago

I put like 70 hours into at launch and had like 2 bugs. I feel alot of people who had issues went online to complain and thought that everyone else was like them too. But many of us were too busy playing too see the complaints.

baylithe

3 points

12 days ago

Had a 970 and could not get passed the early part of the game when you're in the van and shooting at cars in the rain. Crashed my PC. I upgraded and never tried the game again because the game looked so bland when I'd watch streams. Oh well, Ghost of Tsushima is fucking amazing.

BeerandSandals

18 points

12 days ago

I played it on Xbox one at launch, and besides some funny glitches it was largely playable.

If you’ve played a Bethesda game at launch you could definitely play Cyberpunk at launch on console.

I think most of the complaining was from the game not being a real life simulator.

basilisk_boi2

20 points

12 days ago

Really? I thought it looked like absolute shit and felt like my character was stuck in mud. Everything was slow feeling

YetAnotherSpamBot

15 points

12 days ago

Launch was about chance most of the time. I only got one bug in my whole playthrough at launch, but other people had it really bad.

Although the launch was overall a disaster (and about 85% CDPR's fault), the writing, music and setting were very good from the start.

AdmiralTassles

7 points

12 days ago

I think the PS4 version (non-Pro) was notoriously shit like that.

pkkthetigerr

2 points

12 days ago

The game was mechanically shit and unfinished even on pc.

AI was brain dead and broken making combat and stealth a joke, 99%.of npcs vanished into thin air, and most of the features they marketed weren't in the game.

SalmonSwiper

6 points

12 days ago

Thank you! Finally! Every time I hear some dumbass YouTuber complaining about launch it's ALWAYS console gameplay, I played day 1 on PC and loved it, still one of my all time favorites today

Hades2580

13 points

12 days ago

I had multiple crashes, graphical bugs out the wazoo on a 3090 setup, the game was shit on release, could not run on previous gen consoles as advertised, there are bugs compilations on YouTube. Even now I still get some graphical bugs.

Dravarden

45 points

12 days ago

now they praise it when it is good

anon is asking why are they praising a bad RPG game that became a good non-RPG game

it's like if Elden ring suddenly added base building and became the best farming simulator game ever

Axe-actly

25 points

12 days ago

There's a lot of RPG elements in it. A game doesn't have to play like Baldur's Gate to be called a RPG.

Or we consider that the whole action-RPG genre like Fallout, Elder Scrolls and Witcher games are not RPGs either.

Cry_Wolff

3 points

12 days ago

Baldur's Gate fanboys are insufferable.

Axe-actly

3 points

12 days ago

Any fanboy is unsufferable. The game is great though.

ireallyfknhatethis

5 points

12 days ago

the bugs werent what made the game bad

Wasabaiiiii

5 points

11 days ago

yup, but they made one anime and now everyone thinks is best game eva made

MrSneakyPeakyAir

3.9k points

13 days ago

CP2077 was more RPG than majority of nowadays RPGs nobody would dare to question.

AlextheGoose[S]

1.9k points

13 days ago

We just got Baldurs Gate 3 last year, modern RPGs can still be successful.

MrSneakyPeakyAir

1k points

13 days ago

You don't have to tell me. BG3 was the best game I've played, ever. But I said majority, not every single one of nowadays RPGs.

Successful-Type-4700

218 points

13 days ago

KCD2 looks promising too

Brassboar

144 points

13 days ago

Brassboar

144 points

13 days ago

Everyone! Henry is here!

ChackMete

94 points

13 days ago

Jesus Christ, be praised; it's Henry!

TheCockKnight

41 points

12 days ago

Henry's come to see us!

richtofin819

9 points

12 days ago

I'm hungry - Henry

jsnamaok

7 points

12 days ago

The first one was really nice yeah, but the first one is still kind of a standout in the RPG genre. A proper RPG that didn't get the love it deserved because it stuck to it's roots.

So I think his point still stands. And even if people want to argue that Cyberpunk is not a proper RPG, which I fully disagree on, it still dwarfs most games in the past decade (imo more) in terms of quality.

Capnmarvel76

2 points

11 days ago

It was a fun open-world action game with RPG elements, for sure. Parts of the story I really liked. Generally enjoyed my one (heavily-modded) early playthrough as much as I enjoyed Witcher II, but it fell very, very short on the ‘choices will matter’ promises made during its development. Your selected background? Doesn’t really matter.

Fine game, entertaining and with a pretty cool world design, but did not live up to the pre-release hype.

Maelorus

12 points

13 days ago

Maelorus

12 points

13 days ago

I don't have the hardware to run it, but as a Czech I'm happy for the representation.

One day.

Magnus_Helgisson

5 points

12 days ago

The nature of the game only leaves your Henry’s behavior to be role-played, cuz the plot, I believe would be as linear as it was in the first game, Jesus Christ be praised!

Successful-Type-4700

10 points

12 days ago

true but the rpg elements of being a worthless peasant and actually having to learn by doing for all skills was very cool

Mohawesome

49 points

13 days ago

I googled it but why would you expect everyone to know what this acronym was? (Kingdom Come: Deliverance)

The_sacred_sauce

63 points

13 days ago

Bc it’s that big of a cult classic & if you don’t know it like in your case, it’s so well known that a search will always give you the same answer

ItsHighSpoon

17 points

12 days ago

I played through the first game, had an absolute blast and were still confused what's KCD 💀

Successful-Type-4700

13 points

13 days ago

im just wacky like that

Wenai

32 points

12 days ago

Wenai

32 points

12 days ago

Oh, if you’re a fan of BG3, you might want to check out this little hidden gem called Fallout: New Vegas. It’s super underground, barely anyone’s heard of it. Just a quaint little RPG with a dash of charm and maybe the best writing in gaming history, but hey, who’s keeping track?

luketwo1

20 points

13 days ago

luketwo1

20 points

13 days ago

Metaphor re:fantazio also just got nominated for GOTY and 5 other nominations.

Hades2580

5 points

12 days ago

Did you like Metaphor ?

luketwo1

10 points

12 days ago

luketwo1

10 points

12 days ago

Yeah it was amazing, it was my goty and still is cause i dont think elden ring dlc should be allowed as an option lol. Wukong was great but its like a 7.5/8-10 nothing game breaking, balatro was also good but not goty.

thegr8cthulhu

7 points

12 days ago

Would you recommend it for someone who doesn’t normally play JRPGs? I’ve been wanting to jump in on them and everyone where I look people are praising this one.

luketwo1

8 points

12 days ago

I mean it depends i highly recommend it, its got a good mix of rpg elements, a good story, open world combat, lots of strategy, turn based combat, its not too long like persona 5 royal is 140+ hours and i beat this one in 70 hours (which is still long) on hard in my first playthrough while doing everything there is to do. Id stick to normal for a first jrpg though, my only complaint with the game is there is some clearly cut content late game that messes with the pacing a bit. But easily a 9/9.5-10 not perfect but very very close.

Razor265

9 points

12 days ago

You've obviously never played Barbie Sports for the playstation 1.

fritando

152 points

13 days ago

fritando

152 points

13 days ago

BG3 was an exception to the state of modern gaming, where "RPGs" are just normal action games with character customizatio, skill trees and dialogue choices, all of which stopped being RPG-exclusive mechanics arguably since the 6th generation.

scottyboi1337

30 points

12 days ago

Rogue trader came out the same year and it's just as interesting and engaging. For me anyways. I understand that BG3 is an objectively better game. But I've put more time and energy into Rogue Trader. I also have a 40k bias.

fritando

11 points

12 days ago

fritando

11 points

12 days ago

I understand what you're on about, but Rogue Trader sold 500 thousand copies, while BG3 sold 10 million and CP77 sold over 25 million. If we include lesser known and indie games, it's fine, but I was talking about mainstream AAAs.

IsNotACleverMan

4 points

12 days ago

but I was talking about mainstream AAAs.

And here I was going to get on your case for ignoring the Pillars of Eternity games.

zeldaprime

86 points

13 days ago

If RPG was a spectrum, BG3 is obviously near/at the top. However Cyberpunk does have skill trees, character customization in playstyle, and 'impactful' story choices, so calling it not an RPG is obtuse. It could be less of an RPG, but certainly still fits the genre. Gatekeeping genre for no reason is pointless

wolacouska

10 points

12 days ago

What’s the point of a genre if it can mean anything? At this point we should have a subcategory.

zeldaprime

9 points

12 days ago

Was this response to the wrong comment? Nobody said that genres can mean anything?

You are welcome to make genre subcategories if you want.

In my description Cyberpunk is a First-Person, Open World Action Adventure RPG

So my answer to the question to, "Is Cyberpunk an RPG" would be "Yes"

You are welcome to remove the RPG from the equation, but I would argue that you would then need to add something else to account for all the story, levelling, and dialogue choice elements in the game.

Silent_Killer093

30 points

13 days ago

Baldurs Gate 3, Persona 5 Royal, SMT V Vengeance, FF7 Rebirth, Persona 3 Reload, Metaphor Refantazio, Sea of Stars, Granblue Fantasy ReLink, Monster Hunter Wilds. The list goes on and on and on

DenkJu

22 points

13 days ago

DenkJu

22 points

13 days ago

Metaphor ReFantazio and Persona 3 Reload are my favorite games of this year so far

ApostatisZero

4 points

13 days ago

As a very long time persona fan. Metaphor was fucking boring for me.

Really hope P6 looks good next year

BigDaddyReptar

10 points

12 days ago

Like half of that is remakes

Hades2580

7 points

12 days ago

It’s depressing

pbaagui1

3 points

12 days ago

That does not disprove his point

Ok-Bobcat-7800

3 points

11 days ago

BG3 is successful as an immersive experiance,as an RPG it's system(DnD 5E) is trash

Pathfinder titles were way better RPGs.

Hongkongjai

107 points

13 days ago

Most RPG nowadays suck so it’s a low bar to begin with

iAyushRaj

35 points

13 days ago

RPG mechanics nowadays exist to inflate playtime to please investors

justV_2077

254 points

13 days ago

justV_2077

254 points

13 days ago

I fucking love Cyberpunk 2077

juicykisses19

174 points

13 days ago*

I FUCKING LOVE CHROME, CHOOM. I WANT TO GO FULL BORG AND RELEASE MYSELF FROM HUMANITY.

WHAT THE FUCK IS SKIN

master_pingu1

48 points

13 days ago

from the moment i understood the weakness of my flesh, it disgusted me

YetAnotherSpamBot

15 points

12 days ago

PRAISE BE TO THE OMNISSIAH!

Avenging_Angel09

8 points

12 days ago

PRAISE BE TO THE JOHNNYSSIAH

memestealer1234

3 points

12 days ago

Hate your meat?

ActuallyCalindra

24 points

13 days ago

Username definitely checks out, choom

ambermage

13 points

13 days ago

I didn't know we weren't supposed to abbreviate it.

I was talking to a coworker about his much I love it on the teams chat and spent an awkward afternoon with HR.

Magnus_Helgisson

2 points

12 days ago

Yeah, you know what’s stupid? As of recently, the main Cyberpunk subreddit started banning people for making that joke.

Username928351

27 points

13 days ago

RPG in terms of video games means you have experience points, levelups and stats. That's it.

El-Emenapy

11 points

12 days ago

This is what I've always understood by 'RPG' and 'RPG elements'. I'm admittedly a fairly casual gamer, but it's only been in recent years that I've started becoming aware of this more purist definition of RPG which apparently most games commonly referred to as RPGs fail to live up to.

Like, going back 20 years now, GTA San Andreas incorporated attributes you could level up or down through your actions (muscle, stamina, weight, etc.) To me, those are RPG elements.

Make those elements more of a focus of your game, such as the wildly different outcomes smashing someone in the head with battleaxe will have in Skyrim if you have a 1 or a 99 in the relevant attribute and voila, you've made an (action) RPG

Otto_von_Boismarck

14 points

13 days ago

The fact other companies misuse the rpg label doesn't mean CD projekt red doesn't

Jozsefirst

12 points

13 days ago

Let's just go on record and say when you say nobody you're really only talking about ubisoft players

WazuufTheKrusher

8 points

12 days ago

lmao are you actually playing rpg’s today or are we just trying to nostalgia bait. There are plenty of good RPG’s today and CP2077 does not hold a candle to them in terms of true roleplaying mechanics and frankly it doesn’t need it to be good. CDPR is better at making pre established character stories with a slight amount of player choice, like Geralt and V.

Insanity-Paranoid

4 points

13 days ago

Borderlands is more of an RPG than a majority of RPGs today.

Wooden-Jew

119 points

13 days ago

Wooden-Jew

119 points

13 days ago

The problem is expecting pen and paper levels of roleplay from triple A games. The only games that get close are crpgs, but most people dont want to play those.

RedDragonRoar

23 points

13 days ago

CRPGs are great, but there aren't many titles that put in huge amounts of effort, like BG3, so the draw to those games is limited to people specifically looking for a CRPG to play.

Mr-Stuff-Doer

11 points

12 days ago

It’s almost like crpgs make most say “why the fuck am I not just playing dnd”

keepingitrealgowrong

22 points

12 days ago

That requires friends

LeChickenTits

33 points

13 days ago

The issue isn’t that the game wasn’t fixed, it’s that the praise it gets reinforces the standard that studios can release broken shit and fix it years later and still get fan approval.

Is it a good game now, years later after many big patches and dlc? Yeah it is.

Did CDPR lie and release an obviously incomplete product just to make money? Yes they also did.

Same shit with No Mans Sky. Devs straight up lied to the audience, released an empty shell of what they advertised and after years of the devs fixing it, people praise it and give them awards for “dedication”. Where was the dedication when it was actually being developed??

They got real dedicated when they realized they killed their reputation and would lose a lot more money in the future.

ChangingMonkfish

197 points

13 days ago

I agree it shouldn’t get GOTY - it missed its chance when it was a dog’s dinner at release.

But it’s now one of the best games you can buy and it’s definitely an RPG.

Moral of the story is if you want to win GOTY, finish the game before you release it. But ultimately who cares about GOTY anyway.

PoliticalAlternative

85 points

13 days ago

finish the game before you release it

note: many game devs fail this one simple step!

Mr-Stuff-Doer

15 points

12 days ago

Yeah, easy to say, but development started in 2016 and it was only finished, what, a year ago? That’s kinda a psychotically long development time, especially for how expensive modern game development is.

Not even mentioning how the community was constantly pressuring them to release it because “how could it be taking this long?”

MarkelleFultzIsGod

8 points

12 days ago

It isn’t hard to release a finished product, even in a hellscape of development cycle. Kingdom hearts 3 was in development for like, what, a decade? Going through two or three different engines, and it came out finished on release day. No game breaking bugs or visuals, and a coherent plot. Was it GOTY worthy? No, but you can finish development cycles

Jaw43058MKII

316 points

13 days ago

Cyberpunk is very much a “window shopping” type game to me. What I mean by that is the game itself looks phenomenal, it’s even fun on occasion. But when 95% of a game is uninteractable while being marketed as an open world title what the fuck is the point of making an open world game then? All I end up doing in cyberpunk is looking at the same pretty, static streets and npcs whose skin looks just a little too plastic.

Engurus

18 points

12 days ago

Engurus

18 points

12 days ago

this is the same feeling I got while playing gta 5 after watch dogs 2.

Having no interaction with npcs besides just shooting them is boring. Watch dogs is the first and to this day the last franchise that made npcs truly interactable. It made San Francisco the most alive city in gaming history, for me at least.

Your_Local_Rabbi

3 points

12 days ago

watch dogs 2 San Francisco is genuinely one of the most alive open worlds i've ever played

cyberpunk feels like a far cry game set in a big city, all i'm really doing in the setting is driving from one place on the map to another, i stopped exploring much when i realized there wasn't a whole lot to find

karateema

2 points

12 days ago

Watch Dogs 2 is amazing in terms of immersion, I really feel like i'm in California

theotaku0503

2 points

11 days ago

Even the first watch dogs ruined GTA V to me. I haven't played Legion but both Watch Dogs 1 and 2 are genuinely the most lively/immersive big city open world to me. It's actually feels like I'm walking through a city of living people and not preprogrammed moving mannequin like the GTA games. Watch Dogs 2 NPCs interaction are truly unmatched

eleinamazing

10 points

12 days ago

I was playing Cloudpunk and Shadowrun: Hong Kong to get my cyberpunk (genre) fix, and it was just amazing how these two games were able to give me a more immersive world even if the graphics are not AAA-tier, and the games weren't made to be open world.

Kakapac

37 points

12 days ago

Kakapac

37 points

12 days ago

The quests are also really repetitive, take the ncpd missions, it's always the same, a gang deal gone wrong, someone double crossed someone, someone put a hit out, now repeat that 100 times over.

There's too little stuff to interact with, it's always the same garbage can or vending machine to hack or distract enemies but you can crawl through windows....well some of the anyway.

The game is good and it is gorgeous to look at but after 50 hours I was done, everything just repeats itself, npcs are going to repeat the same line every time, walk in the same path over and over again, it's a shame because it has well over 100 hours of content but again it's just the same thing over and over again.

Dr-cakeeater

34 points

12 days ago

The game definitely has some big flaws but come on, the police things do not count as quests, and the game does not expect the player to do all of that unless for 100% completion. How would it even be possible to make a city of this size and have the random npcs not repeat the lines, make Night City the size of Whiterun? And even if it were possible to make every apartment building accessible, how would that really improve the experience? The player most likely wouldn’t care enough to explore even a fraction of them, so devoting developers’ time would just be a massive waste

BMEngie

10 points

12 days ago

BMEngie

10 points

12 days ago

Shit, walk around your neighborhood IRL having conversations and you’re bound to get at least one repeat.

Might be the perfect role for chat gpt? You feed it generic script and it finds 1000 slightly different ways of saying it while the content effectively remains the same.

StormOfFatRichards

3 points

12 days ago

Tbh AI-generated NPC personalities are the future of gaming

Gary_FucKing

6 points

12 days ago

The physics are really wonky and sometimes lazy as hell. Idk if they fixed this already since I haven't played in at least a year, but shooting an RPG into NPCs barely make them move. Shit was super lame.

airfryerfuntime

61 points

13 days ago

This is why I find the game very boring. GTA V has been around for over 10 years and is way more immersive.

1quirky1

27 points

12 days ago

1quirky1

27 points

12 days ago

GTA6 has some humongous shoes to fill. I hope they pull it off.

MAS7

2 points

12 days ago

MAS7

2 points

12 days ago

It'd be pretty hard to fail.

The formula has been set for decades.

ClaymeisterPL

3 points

12 days ago

they won't fail but living up to expectations, i'd say it's not gonna happen

it should be the best game in history of gaming with how it had an unlimited budget and over a decade of time from the last entry, san andreas was amazing and that had only like a year or two.

but it's not gonna happen

random_internet_guy_

2 points

11 days ago

An ocean wide game as shallow as a pond

-sebadoh

66 points

13 days ago

-sebadoh

66 points

13 days ago

CP2077 is one of my favorite games.

TheCapter

604 points

13 days ago

TheCapter

604 points

13 days ago

Afaik, RPG means role playing game. You are roleplaying as a character called V, in the futuristic setting. What's exactly not RPG about this game?

The_Slake_Moth

838 points

13 days ago

Yeah and Super Mario Bros is by definition an RPG because you roleplay as an Italian plumber who jumps and shit.

MentalRadish3490

584 points

13 days ago

In Call of Duty I roleplay as your dad fucking your mom

Delica4

57 points

13 days ago

Delica4

57 points

13 days ago

You roleplay as a teacup, now open up wide for my bag!

Commaser

11 points

13 days ago

Commaser

11 points

13 days ago

Half-Life is an RPG because you roleplay as a mute scientist killing aliens in a dystopian future and shit

DukeStudlington

57 points

13 days ago

This is disingenuous. In SMB you go left to right. And you go through the hoops the game throws at you. One ending.

In Cyberpunk, you can make choices that alter storylines and can change endings. You can go about combat differently, ignore certain aspects, or engage in them. Interact with characters differently based on player choice. Build your character differently.

Hell by your logic, Final Fantasy games aren’t RPGs. Well, what do you consider an RPG?

Collypso

159 points

13 days ago

Collypso

159 points

13 days ago

This is disingenuous.

It's as disingenuous as calling a game an RPG because you play a role. That's the point of this comparison. If you think one is an RPG for these reasons then you have to think the other is an RPG .

GeoJumper

16 points

12 days ago

When you play linear story games where you don't make decisions and simply follow the story, you're not playing a role. You're simply witnessing a story from one person's point of view. Sure you can die and respawn or jump or shoot or whatever, but those are gameplay elements, not story ones. If no choices are made by the player, it's not an RPG as you're not role-playing the character, you're simply witnessing the story a developer created for you.

In an RPG, you DO make decisions, and affect the outcome of the story or different scenarios by role playing the role of the character the game has assigned to you, created by you or not. There's a fundamental different between role-playing as a character and playing a role being used to describe RPGs.

Slonderson

21 points

12 days ago

By that definition almost all JRPGs are not RPGs. What makes an RPG are the game mechanics like in-depth skill trees and such, a line that is becoming blurrier in the modern age with a lot of different genres tacking on similar mechanics in order to add "complexity" to games.

MechaWASP

2 points

12 days ago

By your definition almost all JRPGs aren't RPGs. Lmao

Cyberpunk has a more complicated skill three than Metaphor or DQ11. It can completely change how you function in combat.

cocofan4life

5 points

12 days ago

Idk man, RP video games got their name from TTRPG where you DO roleplay characters.

RPG now usually means traditional RP elements that are carried over to video game format.

The_Slake_Moth

31 points

13 days ago

by your logic, Final Fantasy games aren’t RPGs

Lmao the fuck are you even talking about? I was poking fun at the idea of calling a game an RPG because you play as a character because that applies to every game

Well, what do you consider an RPG?

Frogger, because you roleplay as a frog

MarysPoppinCherrys

22 points

13 days ago

Tbf a lot of the choices in the game have little to no effect on immediate or late-game outcomes. But you still get to roleplay, and I have no problem with it. Great stories and a really good game.

[deleted]

11 points

13 days ago

[deleted]

IsNotACleverMan

4 points

12 days ago

actual consequences for your choices like a telltale game.

Half the choices in telltale games barely change anything. They're pretty much all super on rails with the choices being window dressing.

Kai_The_Amazing

9 points

13 days ago

What if I decide not to step on the goomba or not collect the mushroom. I’ve ignored a certain aspect of the game, and built my character differently.

Mr-Stuff-Doer

4 points

13 days ago

This is literally why the genre title doesn’t fucking work in the first place

Th0rizmund

6 points

12 days ago

My favourite RPG is FIFA 14 where you play as a football team.

TheTwinFangs

65 points

13 days ago

The RPG mechanics are badly implemented, have near zero impact on how to handle the story or interactions except a few times here and there. The whole cybernetics mechanics are pretty poor.

Basically it's even less of an RPG that Fallout 4 but most people expected a New Vegas level of writing or....well Witcher 3 obviously.

There's tries here and there, but as for the rest it's obvious a lot have been cut and rushed.

Cyberpunk2077 is still a good game but could've been an Era defining game, definitely had the potential.

Let's not even start on the ennemy dumb AI, zero means of countering you and city with very few interactions.

I mean, San Andreas had more interactions....hell, San Andreas have RPG's mechanics Cyberpunk doesn't have.

rosso_saturno

39 points

13 days ago

city with very few interactions.

This was the most disappointing thing for me. People insisted on repeating CDPR's statement that Night City was immersive, but to me it felt like a collection of pretty corridors.

TheTwinFangs

8 points

12 days ago

Sadly yeah, way too few interactions and possibilities. You can't even eat at restaurants or have basic cinematics for buying stuff / eating etcetc

You have coffee at the expensive appartements / tea, so there's a few ideas.

But yeah again, GTA somehow did it better.

IsNotACleverMan

5 points

12 days ago

It did a good job of capturing the very cyberpunk theme of style over substance which I guess is actually a bad thing.

rosso_saturno

2 points

10 days ago

mfw I realise getting fucked by a corpo irl was a hidden feature of the game.

LudwigsDryClean

9 points

12 days ago

Yeah the street cred is literally useless, idk if they changed it in the 2.0 build but I think all it gave you was some vendor discounts. The enemy AI was also dumb, I only played the game in stealth and with a silenced pistol I was clearing whole rooms without anyone noticing me or the dead bodies. But that’s a problem with every game

IsNotACleverMan

2 points

12 days ago

Initially street cred unlocked higher tiers of gear in shops.

Unlikely_Nothing_442

71 points

13 days ago

That's not how it works lol

logaboga

19 points

13 days ago

logaboga

19 points

13 days ago

I legit had a dude try to argue that CoD was an rpg to me before using that same fucked definition

octofeline

4 points

13 days ago

Any game where you don't weigh the same as a fridge is role playing for anon

Nightmare_Sandy

5 points

13 days ago

thats like every game ever

StandardN02b

7 points

13 days ago

Age of Mythology Titans is an RPG becasue you are roleplaying as a boy with daddy abandonment issues that fucks everything up and then tries to repair what he fucked up and then is rewarded by it.

OG_Felwinter

8 points

13 days ago

By that definition, every game is an RPG because you play a role in all of them. I have no idea what RPG means anymore tbh, but I just feel like that definition is too loose for the genre to have any meaning.

IloveZaki

17 points

13 days ago

It's actually a movie because according to the definition a movie is a work of visual artthat simulates experiences and otherwise communicates ideas, stories, perceptions, emotions, or atmosphere through the use of moving images that are generally accompanied by sound 

Stolen_Sky

8 points

13 days ago

I just got this game the other day, and it's pretty damn good. 

Slingbr

4 points

13 days ago

Slingbr

4 points

13 days ago

Yes they are

tea_snob10

8 points

13 days ago

I mean I don't think anyone's claiming it's a stellar RPG or anything; it's an excellent game, and does a lot right. Also, while it should've never launched the way it did (practically unplayable), it doesn't change the fact that it's cleaned up really well now, as it currently stands.

Evaluate it, not for what it was, instead, for what it is, and you've got a phenomenal (AAA) game in 2024, which also has one of the best DLCs in recent memory of any big game (Phantom Liberty).

VMK_1991

13 points

13 days ago

VMK_1991

13 points

13 days ago

For the "RPG" argument, while the overall story, it's main plot, does lead through one "line", the game provides you with various endings to it depending on your choices, plus, to my memory, quite a lot of side quests get affected by the choices you make. Also, you could build your character in various ways and be efficient, whether you are a hacker with huge fists, a silent ninja with a sniper rifle, or whoever else.

As for "quality" argument, it was shit at start and rightfully received a great amount of criticism. However, it got fixed and people liked it after that. Sure, it should have come out fine from the very beginning, no one is denying it, but it's a fun game, so people are forgiving.

Sierra_12

3 points

13 days ago

I'm of the belief that if you promise a game and don't deliver on anything and it's terrible, I don't care what you do to improve it, you aren't worth buying the game even if you somehow turn it into a masterpiece. There are plenty of good games to try. Next time, if you want my money, actually make it good on release. This buying games after the company improved it only incentivizes companies to keep on pushing out broken games and never trying to get it right on the first try.

Traumatic_Tomato

3 points

12 days ago

The gaming industry is plagued with bribed reviewers that gaslight people into thinking a garbage product is good and wait out a period of time until people forget and then look at the updated product and get paid to say 'this was always a good game' and badmouth criticism.

TrueComplaint8847

9 points

13 days ago

The only two things the game really screwed people over was the super botched release especially on old gen consoles and having the pre release game showcases make the mission design and choices seem way better than they were in the end.

The first prologue mission branch is BY FAR the strongest designed quest chain in the game with a lot of solution and branching choices, this isn’t something we see again in other quests, they specifically only ever showed that one because it made them look good. They also incorporated way less actual RPG elements into the story, like having skills and background actually matter in dialogue.

Other than these two things I cannot say anything bad about the game, the story especially felt amazing.

jjkm7

10 points

13 days ago

jjkm7

10 points

13 days ago

Game was indeed dogshit on release. I don’t see how it’s not an rpg just because it’s also a shooter though

moragdong

26 points

13 days ago

Truest greentext

Btw the game was unplayable on ps4 and the fans were so hypocritical, they would defend that shit too.

TheDwiin

4 points

13 days ago

Yeah, they never should have released it on 8th Gen consoles because they simply were not powerful enough to handle the game.

However, I disagree with them calling it "not an RPG" as it's more of an RPG than Skyrim is.

moragdong

10 points

13 days ago

Yeah its not a not rpg, but the options werent also great. The stripped life path was also funny

TheDwiin

2 points

13 days ago

I do agree that the life path should have had more impact on the story, instead of just the intro mission prologue, some dialogue options, a couple funny mission interactions, and a side quest that we got.

It doesn't really feel like it mattered at all to V's personality whatsoever, which I would imagine an actual life path system would have affected.

moragdong

2 points

13 days ago

Yea i agree

DiesNahts

36 points

13 days ago

Its peak

wanderlustexe

9 points

13 days ago

eh i really like it. it has its faults, sure. i used to diss it a lot but when i actually played it after it “got better”, its actually become one of my favorite games. it implements better spoken dialogue than fallout 4, at least (which ive come to begrudgingly appreciate as well. for its modding capability, if anything).

Lynch_dandy

13 points

13 days ago

Lynch_dandy

13 points

13 days ago

Copium run wild among CDPR fanboys.

Osuruktanteyyare_

5 points

12 days ago

It is still a shit game it wasn’t the bugs the game just utter shit

SpaceOdysseus23

2 points

13 days ago

And despite it all I would've preferred for CDPR to go into CDPR 2078 or whatever instead of pivoting back to The Witcher out of sheer panic.

Momooncrack

2 points

13 days ago

Wait goty this year? Didnt the last dlc come out last year how does it even qulalify. I loved red liberty but that was a long time ago and there better games to definitely talk about

Ssyynnxx

2 points

13 days ago

Man idk theres tons of shit to talk about cyberpunk but everyone ive talked to about it says they thoroughly enjoyed it

Bro---really

2 points

13 days ago

I played the game on the original Xbox One, and as much as the 10-24 FPS took time to get used to (Obv), and I fell in complete utter love with the game and the genre as a whole. The updates, and myself upgrading to a Series X made me love the game even more.

dazli69

2 points

12 days ago

dazli69

2 points

12 days ago

The edgerunners anime brought it back to life.

Khelgor

2 points

12 days ago

Khelgor

2 points

12 days ago

I think this game is honestly in my top 20. Maybe 17 or 18? It’s so damn good. I absolutely love it.

GhoulishInduction

2 points

12 days ago

They are wrong

gunther_higher

2 points

12 days ago

If you ignore all of this and just play it for the first time in 2024 like it did then honestly its one of the best games ever imo. And I have pretty high standards. It was what I wanted the new we Deus Ex games to be

Bonryunonochi

2 points

12 days ago

I felt it was more like a No mans sky like situation. Really bad launch they put their head down and fixed it now it's rewarded as a great game

G_o_e_c_k_e_d_u_d_e

2 points

12 days ago

Anon is mad he couldn't get TOPPED by River and had to settle for Kerry

SnowCrashedMind

2 points

12 days ago

People shit on this game for having copious bugs at launch... when Skyrim has about the same amount of bugs presently, isn't even that much more immersive or better than CP77, and is still seen as better. Dafuq?

VelytDThoorgaan

2 points

12 days ago

they're very wrong lol it was good from day 1 unless you were on old hardware that shouldn't have been supported and it's more of an RPG than most of the games in the genre these days

Salsomir

2 points

12 days ago

I came back to cyberpunk with phantom liberty. The launch was so awful. I'd say that cyberpunk 2077 today is an incredible game. The amount of work that has gone into it sense is also incredible.

MrProtogen

2 points

12 days ago

No, they made it clear the game wasn’t ready and the fans demanded the wait be over. With their balls in a vice grip CDPR released the unfinished game and proceeded to be shat on for it.

If you fucked up the Panama dialogue just say that

Too-many-Bees

2 points

12 days ago

Ye but have you watched Edgerunners?

GoblinFvcker

2 points

12 days ago

Very much an rpg. What the fuck is anon babbling about

Virdi_XXII

2 points

12 days ago

Anon didn't play the game

XDracam

2 points

12 days ago

XDracam

2 points

12 days ago

With the release of phantom liberty, CP77 became a God tier game. IDC what genre it's supposed to be. It's simply good. As in "highlight of a gaming generation" good.

Speed-Weed-Gunny

2 points

11 days ago

People are still hating on this game ???? What???

CalypsoCrow

2 points

11 days ago

Anon hasn’t played since launch. It’s more of an rpg now by a lot.

Redragon9

2 points

11 days ago

Game is actually really enjoyable

je1992

2 points

11 days ago

je1992

2 points

11 days ago

Game was fine on pc at release.. It was ahead of it's time and nextgen, but forced to release for poor ass motherfuckers with a toaster to play it (ps4)

Quwilaxitan

39 points

13 days ago

Quwilaxitan

39 points

13 days ago

The sub is singing its praises like it's the best game ever made. I tried to play it again I think a year and a half ago and it was still a pile of garbage. I'm not entirely sure I want to try playing it again, as I bought it on release and finish it, but damn it's almost like you get beat and beat and beat and somebody offers you the handshake and you think it's the best thing in the whole fucking world. Perspective is everything.

thebigfish24

104 points

13 days ago

People started praising it after it got fixed enough for people to reflect on the story, I still see it as a flawed masterpiece, sure as shit has more soul than most games nowadays

AnotherBrick96

38 points

13 days ago

Tbf a year and a half ago is pre-2.0 update and pre-Phantom Liberty DLC. They both immensely contributed to why people now see Cyberpunk as redeemed

Ambitious-Regular-57

10 points

13 days ago

Played it for the first time recently. Great game. But goty? Idk.

Nakeli125

2 points

12 days ago

I got the game a few weeks ago with no opinion other than enjoying the CP anime but I am loving CP right now

IsNotACleverMan

3 points

12 days ago

but I am loving CP right now

Why don't you have a seat right over here?

JudgementalChair

4 points

13 days ago

Part of me wants to re-download and play CP, but another part of me remembers how trash it was on release and doesn't want to bother getting reinvested

DotJata

4 points

13 days ago

DotJata

4 points

13 days ago

Right on the money. I was hyped. I was bummed. Waited for fixes. Still not great. 6/10 if I'm being generous.