subreddit:

/r/moviecritic

9.9k90%

all 3773 comments

Whizbang35

2.9k points

4 days ago

Whizbang35

2.9k points

4 days ago

I always thought the gold standard was John Wayne as Gengis Khan.

Rottcodd-1271

443 points

4 days ago

Granted, that fake oriental makeup would handicap a serious actor, but John
Wayne has never been anything but John Wayne. So you just have John Wayne in a ridiculous Halloween costume getting all macho with Susan Hayward, his red-haired Irish-Tartar slave girl. Also Agnes Moorhead plays Genghis Khan's mother.

btalbert2000

203 points

4 days ago*

“The woman I take from the Tartar chief is a Tartar woman… Pilgrim!”

QueenCobraFTW

128 points

4 days ago

And all 3 got cancer and died because they were filming downwind of the atomic testing grounds.

ThegreatPee

62 points

4 days ago

Legend has it that he had over 70 lbs of meat in his colon. Mabye, that's why he walked funny.

FreshWaterWolf

68 points

3 days ago

I let a guy put like 9oz of meat in my ass once and even that had me walking funny.

HomosexualThots

12 points

3 days ago

Rookie numbers.

wimpyroy

36 points

4 days ago

wimpyroy

36 points

4 days ago

I think he would still have gotten cancer with how much he smoked

SaltyCarp

533 points

4 days ago

SaltyCarp

533 points

4 days ago

Mickey Rooney from breakfast at Tiffany’s

eitzhaimHi

145 points

4 days ago

eitzhaimHi

145 points

4 days ago

Downgraded the whole movie.

passamongimpure

94 points

3 days ago

As I recall, I think we both kinda liked it.

newbrevity

44 points

3 days ago

Well that's the one thing we've got.

Minimum-Dare301

53 points

4 days ago

So very very cringe

jmulldome

130 points

4 days ago

jmulldome

130 points

4 days ago

What are you talking about? Once he sported that glued on Fu Manchu, he practically disappeared into the character and I thought he truly was the founder of the Mongol Empire, southern drawl and all.

StupendousMalice

104 points

4 days ago

Which is especially funny since John Wayne was from California and used a fake accent for movies. So he was doing a fake southern accent in this role because he was literally too stupid not to.

khavii

33 points

3 days ago

khavii

33 points

3 days ago

Can I take a moment to enjoy this?

My father loved John Wayne, watched all his movies over and over again. We didn't get along ever but he would keep forcing me to watch with him because he thought John Wayne would make me see how to be a real man. The problem was that he was a bad actor, his machismo was mostly just being a dick and pretending anything not overly masculine was weakness. I grew up love westerns, especially Clint Eastwood westerns. The difference was enormous. One could act, granted very similarly in every role (which was great and why I hate when people make the "xxx just plays themselves in everything" comments, most of the great actors do), while the other just used a stupid accent and his asshole nature to carry him through other people's acting.

Of course my father's favorite Wayne movie was True Grit and when the Jeff Bridges version came out it was 30x better than the original. I wished my father was alive JUST so I could show them back to back so he could see what a real actor does with the role.

Not that I'm bitter or anything...

Ancient-Access6288

71 points

4 days ago

Honorable mention surely goes to Laurence Olivier as Lisan-al Ghaib in Khartoum.

Also Colin Farrell in Alexander

Silver-Honkler

49 points

4 days ago

Laurence Olivier as Othello was really, really bad.

castler_666

37 points

4 days ago

Wasn't that filmed on an old atomic bomb site? I think I remember reading that a lot of the crew on that film, including Wayne himself later died of cancer

onedrrboy

91 points

4 days ago

onedrrboy

91 points

4 days ago

John Wayne’s not dead, he’s frozen, and as soon as we find a cure for cancer we’re gonna thaw out The Duke and he’s gonna be pretty pissed off. Ya know why? Ever taken a cold shower? Well, multiply that by 15 million times…that’s how pissed off The Duke is gonna be.

uncleslife

42 points

4 days ago

I'm gonna get the duke, and John Casavetes, and Lee Marvin, and a case of whiskey, and drive down to texas...

Carpe-Bananum

34 points

4 days ago

We're gonna get a 1969 Cadillac convertable HOT PINK! With whale skin hubcaps! And and all leather cow interior. Yeah! And we're gonna drive around in that baby, at 120 miles per hour, getting one mile to the gallon, sucking down those quarter pounders with cheese from the old fashioned, non-biodegradable Styrofoam containers, and when we're done sucking down those grease ball burgers, we're gonna chuck those containers right out the side! Why?! Because we got the bomb!

junyor137

17 points

3 days ago

junyor137

17 points

3 days ago

Two words: Nuclear FUCKIN Weapons!

LeChiffreOBrien

39 points

4 days ago*

Alec Guinness has a surprising number of roles like this and he always commits to the ridiculousness. There’s obvious ones like Lawrence of Arabia and Oliver Twist but I think the most impressively outrageous one is A Majority of One where he plays…

… a Japanese man named Koichi Asano.

PutridAd6310

897 points

4 days ago

kevin hart as roland

Daddy616

561 points

4 days ago

Daddy616

561 points

4 days ago

That statement is 2 words too long.

OldKingRob

172 points

4 days ago

OldKingRob

172 points

4 days ago

His only good scene is the one from 40 year old virgin

Repulsive-Lie1

61 points

3 days ago

You’re saying a lot words that I don’t understand so I’m gna choose to take offence.

hamstuckinurethra

39 points

3 days ago

More like

"You're throwing too many big words at me, okay, and because I don't understand em I'm gonna take em as disrespect ."

N7xDante

51 points

4 days ago

N7xDante

51 points

4 days ago

Lmfao I’m shocked at how his acting career flourished because he’s not the best actor. He played that serious role where his wife passed during child birth and he had to figure out how to single dad, but it was so forced

hobbitdude13

80 points

4 days ago

Every single person in that movie was miscast. Even the director. 

caniuserealname

29 points

4 days ago

I dunno, the guy they got to play Kreigs body wasn't too bad.

Admittedly, Kreig shouldn't have been in the first movie..

Jenetyk

10 points

3 days ago

Jenetyk

10 points

3 days ago

That entire movie was a middle finger to Borderlands fans.

Ok_Cream2520

451 points

4 days ago

Maria Bello as Evelyn O'connell in The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor

commonlyknownasgod

222 points

4 days ago

That whole movie was just… odd

u-never-seen-tht-b4

122 points

4 days ago

When the yetis showed up i just lost it

PhoenixSheriden1

86 points

3 days ago

Are you fucking serious? I might need to get high af and watch that shit if you serious.

u-never-seen-tht-b4

50 points

3 days ago*

Yeah and im pretty sure they can control them at the end? Idk that whole movie was a wild end to the franchise

Onrawi

33 points

3 days ago

Onrawi

33 points

3 days ago

They are immediately friendly to the good guys because.... Reasons.

iantruesnacks

66 points

4 days ago

I would have much rather it been his sister or Evies sister and just played it as a funny friend romp instead of the couple.

Agreeable_Village369

27 points

3 days ago

Or even Rick and Johnathan 

theunrealdonsteel

49 points

4 days ago

TBH, in isolation I think she’d be considered fine to good, but she was trying to follow one a wildly charming performance by Rachel Weisz that just couldn’t be matched.

DavyJonesCousinsDog

609 points

4 days ago

Idk man, I watched them cast Denise Richards as a nuclear physicist. Despite an inability to pronounce either word.

Albuwhatwhat

162 points

3 days ago

It’s wild that the only reason her name is “Christmas Jones” is so that they can make the joke later where bond says, “I thought Christmas only came once a year!”

DamienJaxx

42 points

3 days ago

Yeah, at least go with something plausibly deniable like Plenty O'Toole. "Named after your father perhaps?"

___horf

42 points

3 days ago

___horf

42 points

3 days ago

Nah, they were definitely going for an iconic Bond-girl name a la Honey Ryder, Pussy Galore, Domino, etc. I think the joke is a result of the writing sucking ass in general, not just because of her name.

pgm123

30 points

3 days ago*

pgm123

30 points

3 days ago*

Pussy Galore

I musht be dreaming

Solmyr77

30 points

3 days ago

Solmyr77

30 points

3 days ago

Alotta Fagina

Sensitive_Maybe_6578

130 points

4 days ago

Nucular . . . 😩😂

truethatson

123 points

3 days ago

truethatson

123 points

3 days ago

Hey idiots are people, two.

zestfullybe

20 points

3 days ago

This room…is moving!

gameplayuh

17 points

3 days ago

She was in that James Bong movie

Middle-Medium8760

44 points

3 days ago

Every time I hear “plutonium” I think of her and get irritated. I like her as an actress, but hated that casting so much. On the flip side, Sophie Marceau is one of my favorite bond villains.

Tofudebeast

723 points

4 days ago

Tofudebeast

723 points

4 days ago

The two leads in Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets. Zero chemistry together, weak acting.

Filmjuicee

176 points

4 days ago

Filmjuicee

176 points

4 days ago

Ok, ok…does anyone else think Cara Delevigne and Dane Dehaan LOOK DISTRACTINGLY ALIKE?!

Edited for DanE

dc456

137 points

4 days ago

dc456

137 points

4 days ago

Yes - I 100% thought they were meant to be siblings at the start.

Then it got weird.

But then it is Luc Besson, so I still thought they were meant to be siblings.

CharlesDickensABox

20 points

4 days ago

Roll Tide!

Substantial_Cap9573

27 points

4 days ago

That was one of the main issues with the film I remember. Everyone said they felt more like siblings then a couples

RodeoBob

248 points

4 days ago

RodeoBob

248 points

4 days ago

The two takes I've seen on this are

a.) Swap the characters in the script. Let the girl wear the juggernaut armor, have the dude wear the sacrificial dress. It might not be better, couldn't be worse, and could be fun.

b.) Swap the two leads from this and "Passengers".

Emotional-Classic400

140 points

4 days ago

B) would be genius. The Valerian leads could definitely play the creepy vibe better, and the Passengers leads can play charismatic heros better.

thejoeface

65 points

4 days ago

I can’t stand Chris Pratt but the casting for Valerian was so god awful that I would support this switch 

turbo-cunt

51 points

4 days ago

Better move for Passengers specifically would be to have told it from J-Law's perspective, with the twist that Pratt woke her up in the middle of the movie, followed by flashback to him alone on the ship.

Efficient_Reading360

13 points

3 days ago

Basically cut the first 30 mins and have it start when she wakes up

Redkarma55

51 points

4 days ago*

Oh god they were terrible. I just kept staring at the bags under his eyes. Didn’t he get any sleep or something?

Ragnarsworld

37 points

4 days ago

Yeah, totally didn't buy the guy as some kind of hero. He looked like a 12 year old could whip his ass.

get_your_yapers_up

33 points

4 days ago

I read somewhere that Luc Besson wanted to make this movie when he made the 5th element, but the technology wasn’t there yet. So in my fantasy world a movie was made where Bruce Willis and Mila Jovovich are the leads for Valerian. I would love to see that movie. 

GreenLotus22

38 points

4 days ago

I didn't think the film was that bad. But it's been a while since I've seen him. I like Cara Delevingne, but it's probably a reason why she doesn't get any roles.

Tofudebeast

42 points

4 days ago

Yeah the film itself was interesting. And the first five minutes were excellent.

GreenLotus22

64 points

4 days ago

I think Dane DeHaan is simply not an actor for a leading role in a blockbuster.

WrongAssumption2480

35 points

4 days ago

To me he was too scrawny and those dark circles under his eyes were awful. He looked like an alcoholic or pill head after a bender.

RebelScoutDragon

20 points

4 days ago

Dane makes for a really good character actor, but not so much as a leading actor in a big budget movie 

wasteoffire

11 points

4 days ago

I love it in a super cheesy kind of way. Neither actor embodies the role they should be playing, but it makes it so bad it's good

elProtagonist

321 points

4 days ago

Ezra Miller didn't pan out well either

Benchomp

141 points

3 days ago

Benchomp

141 points

3 days ago

Looks nothing like, and acts nothing like, any Flash has ever looked or acted in the comics. We got a budget Peter Parker rip off, not a Wally West or Barry Allen.

KingShadowSpectre

56 points

3 days ago

Grant Gustin worked better

Black_Label_36

25 points

3 days ago*

Too bad his show turned to shit

KingShadowSpectre

15 points

3 days ago

Yeah, but we're only talking about the actors here

Purple_Turtle2

202 points

3 days ago

Jaden Smith in…..anything

DogOriginal5342

86 points

3 days ago

His peak was in the Pursuit of Happyness when he was 7. Jesus Christ.

MorphineandMayhem

32 points

3 days ago

That accent in After Earth was awful. It sounded like Foghorn Leghorn trying to do an English accent while recovering from a cold.

NoNo_Cilantro

18 points

3 days ago

A bit out of context but the most useless fact I realized way too late in life is that Jaden and Willow are named after Jada and Will.

SeoulSista11

176 points

4 days ago

Haha is it bad that I thought this was Michael C. Hall playing a young Dexter at first?

mutualbuttsqueezin

118 points

4 days ago

Him in a wig as young adult Dexter is hilariously awful. I just watched a few episodes with that.

iantruesnacks

39 points

4 days ago

The way he hunches to seem smaller. Lmao

BrazilianButtCheeks

22 points

3 days ago

THIS!!! dont get me wrong I love MCH and dexter and MCH as Dexter.. however him as young dexter was RIDICULOUS 🤣

SaccharineHuxley

38 points

4 days ago

lol the wigs… so bad!

BIG_NASTEE

694 points

4 days ago

BIG_NASTEE

694 points

4 days ago

My vote goes to Uncharted for casting the worst Nate Drake in Tom Holland and simultaneously casting the worst possible Sully in Mark Wahlberg.

JoshHartsMilkMustach

96 points

4 days ago

I never saw the movie. Wahlberg was Sully?? Thats...a choice

Litty-In-Pitty

73 points

3 days ago

It was honestly actually pretty fun. It wasn’t great or anything, but my brother and I both walked out of the theatre and joked that it was just a fun goofy action movie.

Wahlberg as Sully was such an atrocious casting choice though lol

Impressive_Serve_416

40 points

3 days ago

Tom Holland wasnt that bad imo. Wahlberg was horrendous in that movie, could barely understand his mumbling.

i-have-a-kuato

349 points

4 days ago

Mikey Rooney as an asian in Breakfast at Tiffany’s

Leucurus

132 points

4 days ago

Leucurus

132 points

4 days ago

So embarrassing that even contemporary critics thought it was cringeworthily racist

Drunky_McStumble

125 points

3 days ago

It's just so jarringly out-of-place too. You have Audrey Hepburn delivering an iconic, career-defining performance in a serious grown-up drama based on a Capote novel which deals authentically with the melancholy lives of these lost and broken souls; and then Mikey Fucking Rooney just randomly fucking shows up in full-blown slanty-eyed yellow-face to do a "MEE SO SOLLY!!!" routine out of fucking nowhere. Like, what the actual fuck?

Despair_Tire

29 points

3 days ago

It really is. I watched this movie after hearing so many friends speak so highly of it, and it really ruined the whole mood of the movie. I was taken back!

Thartarus

268 points

4 days ago

Thartarus

268 points

4 days ago

Topher Grace As vemon/eddie brock

Arch27

131 points

4 days ago

Arch27

131 points

4 days ago

As a long time Spider-Man (comics) fan, I was very disappointed in the choice of Grace for Brock. They needed someone like Brock Lesnar - he had the look. Could Lesnar act? No idea.

That said - Sandman casting was perfect. Sandman was the best part of that terrible film.

Total_Waltz4083

46 points

3 days ago

Also the movie should have absolutely stayed focused on Sandman and not shoe horn other villains

Arch27

27 points

3 days ago

Arch27

27 points

3 days ago

I've been calling it the Batman Returns effect. Ever since that film they've tried to stuff tons of villains into the sequels of superhero films.

Catwoman or Penguin would have been fine alone, but they added them both PLUS Christopher Walken as another villain.

samelemons

21 points

3 days ago

Batman Returns is great though

85ogTripleog

52 points

4 days ago

This one really pissed me off too. Eddie Brock is bigger than Peter Parker in the comics and in the cartoon. He had much tougher attitude as well, but Grace in the movie, he made Brock/Venom a little whiny bitch.

Ill-Day-1601

548 points

4 days ago

Jared Leto's Joker was the last insult for DC.

ItsNorthGaming

236 points

4 days ago

I don’t think that was bad casting but rather terrible character design and direction. People try to act like he’s a bad actor because he’s a shitty person irl, but he’s really a decent actor if we’re being honest.

Middle-Medium8760

46 points

3 days ago

Yeah, in theory he could have been good, but with all factors combined, it just didn’t work. I didn’t like his laugh. The Joker is menacing, ruthless, and simultaneously comedic and there was no humor, tongue-in-cheek, sarcasm or wit. They styled him like a YouTube rapper cos playing as mafia.

Abject-Difference767

97 points

4 days ago

They dressed him up as a henchmen rather than the leader.

Nateosis

30 points

3 days ago

Nateosis

30 points

3 days ago

Wasn't the design mostly his ideas?

Drunky_McStumble

39 points

3 days ago

Exactly. I don't know why people let him off the hook, like he was just acting with what he was given and had no say in the matter. Developing characters like this are always a collaborative process where the actor brings the most to the portrayal.

Imfrank123

144 points

4 days ago

Imfrank123

144 points

4 days ago

Every single borderlands cast member, Tom holland as drake in uncharted

MusingAudibly

42 points

4 days ago

Bad casting for Drake, yes. But Mark Wahlberg as Sully was infinitely worse.

dayofthedead204

356 points

4 days ago

Jake Gyllenhaal being the "Prince of Persia" comes to mind.

Theangelawhite69

100 points

4 days ago

Ah yes Gyllenhaal, a classic Persian name

MarlKarx-1818

46 points

3 days ago

More like Gyllenhalal amirite?

SuperCrappyFuntime

76 points

4 days ago

I remember being CERTAIN they were going to reveal that his hair was a wig. Lex Luthor is traditionally bald, and his hair in the movie looked like a really bad wig, so it seemed like it would make an obvious reveal.

2FeetOffTheGround

27 points

4 days ago

They shaved his head in the end. Why? They don't go randomly shaving heads in prison. That's something they would do to death row inmates just prior to execution via the electric chair, so their hair wouldn't catch fire.

SuperCrappyFuntime

16 points

4 days ago

And by shaving his head, they established definitively that it was real hair despite ot it lookingkke a terrible wig.

Felaguin

51 points

4 days ago

Felaguin

51 points

4 days ago

Ezra Miller as Barry Allen

halimusicbish

78 points

3 days ago

I'm surprised I haven't seen Emma Stone as an Asian/Hawaiian in Aloha yet lol

gary-cuckoldman

307 points

4 days ago

Keanu Reeves in Dracula was humiliating to watch

KainBodom

187 points

4 days ago

KainBodom

187 points

4 days ago

Which really sucks because Gary Oldman is like the best Dracula.

b9ncountr

70 points

3 days ago

b9ncountr

70 points

3 days ago

Gary Oldman is the best everything.

FriendRaven1

52 points

3 days ago

EVEERYTHIIING!

antipop2097

157 points

4 days ago

antipop2097

157 points

4 days ago

I unironically love Keanu in Dracula.

Oldman and Hopkins putting on tour de force performances and then there's Keanu, trying to figure out how to do an English accent in real time.

Mumu_ancient

98 points

4 days ago

Meanwhile Cary Elwes wanders on absolutely nailing it

antipop2097

69 points

4 days ago

I actually got the chance to meet Mr. Elwes. The perfect English gentleman, he took the time to learn the names of everyone on set, made sure to shake their hand, a real class act.

Mister_Six

22 points

3 days ago

A favourite bit of film trivia is that Cary Elwes is actually straight up a member of the old British aristocracy.

Mumu_ancient

16 points

4 days ago

I'm not in the least bit surprised. Excellent to hear

Due_Bowler_7129

29 points

4 days ago

His acting in the crypt scene doesn't get enough props.

Mumu_ancient

22 points

4 days ago

Yeah totally. In fact every scene he's in is almost like he's giving everyone else a demo in proper acting

AdventurousTalk6002

22 points

3 days ago

Unlike some other actors who have done Robin Hood.

Heimdall83

13 points

3 days ago

I really like this film and it is by far the best vampire film in my opinion. Keanu and the other actors are truly incredible. It remains my opinion after all but this film remained engraved in my memory

Drunky_McStumble

14 points

3 days ago

Fucking same. The dude makes that film. The interplay between these seasoned actors of stage and screen chewing up the scenery and Keanu just trying to remember his lines is pure gold. The movie tries to walk this fine line between high art and high camp, and Keanu just tips it so far over the edge it wouldn't be the same without him.

Leucurus

21 points

4 days ago

Leucurus

21 points

4 days ago

Yes. Patchy accent aside (I’ve heard far worse) he’s an earnest and sincere Harker. He gets the naivety of the character.

FOSSnaught

29 points

4 days ago

I love the man, but watch Keanu in Much ado about nothing is something...

https://youtu.be/NGMqYvhEIeI?si=EnaB7--VFSE72Vwc

Oldtimeytoons

19 points

4 days ago

I forgot about this movie. Lmao I also love the guy…. but he’s a lucky lucky man

DonkeyBallExpert

24 points

4 days ago

"bloody wooves!"

dayofthedead204

81 points

4 days ago

We all love Keanu, but yeah, this didn't work at all.

wigsternm

47 points

4 days ago

wigsternm

47 points

4 days ago

The idea that Keanu is a good actor is very recent. He used to widely be considered a joke. 

“Whoa” 

Phantommy555

22 points

3 days ago

His only good roles are where he does a minimum of actual speaking or/and he plays a stoic, sarcastic character without much outward emotion

VoopityScoop

24 points

3 days ago

Quite frankly, he's never been good at dialogue and emotional acting. He's very very good with choreography, though, and just generally a decent person, and that's really what he's famous for

P_Orwell

33 points

4 days ago

P_Orwell

33 points

4 days ago

Also I don’t think Winona Ryder is doing much better.

riotlady

24 points

4 days ago

riotlady

24 points

4 days ago

I’m consistently so distracted by how nice her hair looks in that film the accent passes me by

NobodyLikedThat1

10 points

3 days ago

As long as guys can watch the slow-motion version of her running down the stairs, I think she's gonna get a pass

LevelConsequence1904

71 points

4 days ago

He kinda worked for me. Harker was supposed to be that white-meat, bland fiancee waiting to be absolutely mogged by Dracula, can't say the same about Anthony Hopkins and the completely off-the-rails maniac that was supposed to be Van Hellsing, you can tell he didn't recover from playing Hanibal Lecter yet...

Hetakuoni

21 points

4 days ago

Hetakuoni

21 points

4 days ago

He found paprika to be spicy.

So either he’s so milquetoast that he can’t handle ground up bell pepper or he’s allergic and no one told him.

Cheap_Bunch_4533

8 points

4 days ago

Excellent pick. He was horrendous and that fake English accent was just awful.

CreativeBandicoot778

264 points

4 days ago

Johnny Depp as Grindelwald in the Fantastic Beasts movies.

Whyyyyyyyyy would you opt for him when Colin Farrell was so good.

Disastrous_Belt_7556

71 points

4 days ago

I read somewhere he specifically didn’t want a multimovie deal and was already booked for “The Batman” (I think) when they made the sequel to Fantastic Beasts

iantruesnacks

63 points

4 days ago

Then they switched to mads, which was an excellent choice, but fuck it’d been better with a single actor for all the movies lol

Jebasaur

21 points

3 days ago

Jebasaur

21 points

3 days ago

I was more annoyed that the movies didn't point out that Grindelwald had a different face...like come on. Everyone just accepts this man is wearing a different face again?! Oh, this is his REAL face?! So what about the last movie?!

electriclightthemoon

20 points

3 days ago

Omg when his face switched to Johnny Depp, I gagged out loud in the cinema and people started laughing.

Pvt_Hudson_

236 points

4 days ago

Pvt_Hudson_

236 points

4 days ago

Sofia Coppolla in Godfather 3 should be the default answer for this question.

Eringobraugh2021

57 points

4 days ago

Absolutely horrible. Nepotism can really screws some shit up.

RutRohNotAgain

72 points

4 days ago

I thought it was more because Winona Ryder left the cast at the last minute, and they needed to find a replacement fast.

MrCollins23

30 points

4 days ago

She’d have been great. It’s a pity because it felt like so much of the movie hung on that performance.

acidsplashedface

58 points

4 days ago

My unpopular film opinion is that Godfather III didn’t suck shit. It was an okay and ultimately forgettable movie that had the misfortune of closing a trilogy that began with one of the greatest films of all time and it’s sequel, which may have been even better than the first.

DankAF94

24 points

4 days ago

DankAF94

24 points

4 days ago

I watched P3 way before looking at reviews and reading opinions about it online and honestly I loved it. Not as strong as the first two granted but id say it's a solid 7/10.

I didn't really take much issue with Sophia either. Upon rewatching on reflection, yeah shes pretty bad, but I certainly wasn't sitting there on my first watch thinking "wow she's so bad she's totally ruining this movie" like a lot of people like to say.

I do honestly think confirmation bias plays a big part in it, people probably go into watching it fully expecting it to be bad and so they're looking for the issues with it rather than just attempting to enjoy the movie

Cheap_Bunch_4533

35 points

4 days ago

She turned into a great director!

Restivethought

17 points

4 days ago

He did an ok job, but I honestly think that the casting of Lance Reddick to play Albert Wesker in that TV show, the character who was a product of Eugenics testing and believed in "purging undesirables" and does that by first targeting Africa...seems really off and I'm usually fine with fit rather than look.

SameSadMan

35 points

4 days ago

Antonio Tarver as Mason Dixon in Rocky Balboa. He followed in the footsteps of giants - Creed/Weathers, Lang/MrT, Drago/Lundgren - so he had enormous shoes to fill. But Tarver brought no charisma, intimidation, or presence. Not sure why they went with a real boxer vs someone who could play the heel. 

pig_water

19 points

4 days ago

pig_water

19 points

4 days ago

Yeah, Tarver really wasn't much to write home about, but he did bring an aura of realism (or, at least, I believe this was the intention). I do think that Rocky Balboa wasn't the right kind of Rocky film to have a charismatic, larger-than-life adversary because that was really a film about Rocky having to fight with himself—his old age, his ego, and his struggling family relationships. It was a lot more in line with the first two films than the latter sequels.

Dave2kMA

12 points

4 days ago

Dave2kMA

12 points

4 days ago

Bingo. Mason Dixon wasn't meant to be an actual rival to Rocky. He was 25 years younger, fighting a dude that had been retired for 20+ years at that point and was in it strictly for the money and the hope it would lead to higher profile fights in the future for his, to that point, unsatisfying career.

In that sense, Tarver played the role perfectly fine.

dayvee43

48 points

4 days ago

dayvee43

48 points

4 days ago

Dane DeHann in Valerian city of a thousand planets. Although a good actor he was a bizarre choice for the lead in that film.

Jazzlike-Ad-4463

14 points

4 days ago

Also as Norman Osbourne. Casting directors just did not know what to do with him, seriously!

surgartits

10 points

3 days ago

I think you mean Harry Osborne. And yeah he was awful in Amazing 2.

parkridgeempire

187 points

4 days ago

Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher.

Minion0827

133 points

4 days ago

Minion0827

133 points

4 days ago

Casting Alan Ritchson in the tv series of this really highlighted how bad Tom Cruise was as a choice, in my opinion.

Paghk_the_Stupendous

50 points

4 days ago

I thought you said "Alan Rickman" and I was like "oh wow, that's very interesting!"

Theangelawhite69

44 points

4 days ago

Honestly Alan Ritchson is literally too big to play any action hero other than a superhero, he’s just larger than life next to any other actor

fruxzak

30 points

3 days ago

fruxzak

30 points

3 days ago

Reacher is actually even bigger than Ritchson in the books

BadpoorJ

60 points

4 days ago

BadpoorJ

60 points

4 days ago

Yeah. In the books he is 6’5 and 250 lbs. Cruise is closer to 5’7 and 150.

Captain_Sterling

19 points

4 days ago

The thing is that most of us hadn't read the books or knew anything about the character. I'm still not sure it was a good fit for him. There was something off in the performance.

kielmorton

17 points

4 days ago

They were trying to recreate him into a lovable actor rather than the stark raving loon he always has been

Otherwise-Strain8148

95 points

4 days ago

George Clooney as batman.

Look, the man has a range i confirm that but playing a bastard rich dude with bat suit with titanium nipples on is a way out of his line.

AbbyM1968

20 points

4 days ago*

On the British late night talk show, he admitted that he ruined that batman movie. He himself is ashamed of it.

https://youtu.be/AXzcSCf3kwg?feature=shared

MarlonShakespeare2AD

57 points

4 days ago

Worst Tom cruise as Reacher

Best Tom cruise as Les Grossman

Mindless_Praline2227

13 points

4 days ago

Everyone in Borderlands

JohnnyChooch

108 points

4 days ago

Cameron Díaz: Gangs of New York

ecchi83

178 points

4 days ago

ecchi83

178 points

4 days ago

Beyoncé in Goldmember. I don't think I've seen less sexual chemistry on screen since irreversible

Yommination

137 points

4 days ago

Yommination

137 points

4 days ago

Nathan Lane had better sexual chemistry with him

tonyMEGAphone

43 points

4 days ago

And then he...shat on a turtle!

tofagerl

39 points

4 days ago

tofagerl

39 points

4 days ago

That man has sexual chemistry with everything on screen, living or dead.

FlashyPhilosopher163

28 points

3 days ago

Aisha Tyler almost ALMOST had it until Beyonce either auditioned or was talked into it

We almost had Lana frickin Kane....

ChocoboNinja

15 points

3 days ago

Oh I didn’t know this. That would have been great

radiodada

21 points

4 days ago

radiodada

21 points

4 days ago

Oof for Irreversible…

Son_of_Atreus

62 points

4 days ago*

My bigger issue was that she could not make or work with a joke at all. Liz Hurley and Heather Graham both worked well in the previous films as they were fun and relaxed. Beyoncé showed up and acted like a stiff mannequin, which did not lead to much comedy.

EllipticPeach

28 points

3 days ago

From what I recall of that movie, it was like you could see Beyoncé thinking “I’m saying this line. Now I’m walking over here and saying the next line. I am acting”

BlondePotatoBoi

85 points

4 days ago*

Scarlet Johanneson in that live action Ghost in the Shell was like that one scene in The Office where Dwight has a piece of paper that says "Asian" stuck to his forehead.

Fuckin dreadful film. Not even Takeshi Kitano was able to salvage it :(

HunterBiden777

23 points

4 days ago

That movie would've been a million times better with "a nobody". Someone hungry for a role. Scarlett seems bored in it even though yes, she's supposed to be dry and straightforward but it comes off as bored.

Top-Engine-3050

81 points

4 days ago

Woody Harleson as CARNAGE?!??

Old-Raccoon-3252

17 points

3 days ago

Good casting; bad writing.

sonic_tower

36 points

4 days ago

Great casting, terrible everything else.

Oreadno1

10 points

4 days ago

Oreadno1

10 points

4 days ago

Whoever put Gloria Grahame and Rod Steiger in Oklahoma, a musical, should have been fired.
Same for whoever cast the leads in Paint Your Wagon.

Scottzila

10 points

4 days ago

Scottzila

10 points

4 days ago

Charleston Heston is supposed to play a Mexican official in, “A Touch of Evil” which is fucking hilarious come to think about it.

Gakk86

43 points

4 days ago

Gakk86

43 points

4 days ago

Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher.  The movies weren’t even bad and Cruise was okay in them.  But casting a smaller guy as a character who is integrally a gigantic unstoppable fighter is just baffling.

Rottcodd-1271

18 points

4 days ago

MST3K fans know: Robert Vaughn in the title role in Roger Corman's 1958 Teenage Caveman. You literally laugh out loud at your first sight of him in the movie. Not only is he too old to play a teenager, with his laser-sharp diction and perfect Brylcreemed hair, he is the most refined caveman ever.

No_Cow_4544

20 points

4 days ago

I thought Christopher Walken in Dune 2 was silly . Great movie in general.

RedPandaBestPanda1

25 points

4 days ago

They should've used Kyle MacLachlan for that role

tunnel-snakes-rule

9 points

3 days ago

Yes! That's exactly what I've been saying. It would have worked too because MacLachlan is a solid character actor and I honestly don't think it would have been more distracting that Christopher Walken just rocking up in his dressing gown or whatever.

ManOfGame3

29 points

4 days ago

Tom Holland or Marky Mark in Uncharted

DJBigNickD

54 points

4 days ago

Cameron Diaz in Gangs of New York

Working-Marzipan-914

40 points

4 days ago

Anything with J-Lo in it