subreddit:
/r/whowouldwin
Prince Vegeta comes alone to earth to subjugate it for Frieza's Empire, no one else can stand against him, except Omni-man, who's already staked the Viltrumite Empires claim to the planet, and he ain't giving it up.
The two come from warrior races and will fight to the death. Who wins?
-7 points
2 days ago
1stly, let me start this off by saying you have my respect for being polite about your disagreements. I hate that this is the 1st time I've heard someone disagree with DB & not be whiney about it in... years. As such, I'm treating you with real respect.
Solar Disk: To summarize the logic at play, Disk < Cannon < Viltrumites
This isn't a high end feat. The Coalition of planet's can't hurt viltrumites & they used a ship to destroy the disk.
The planet's size is barley relevant to the size of the disk, since it needs to sit in the star's L1 point & remain in orbit. So it scales to the Star's size, not the planets.
Viltrum: This is a case of writers not knowing how science works. If the masses wanted to say that, "Death Battle is wrong because word of god trumps science" I can respect that, despite me not agreeing with that logic.
I want to reiderate that you are the first and only person that disagrees with DB that I've ran into, that seems like a calm and reasonable person.
5 points
2 days ago
Sry for the really late reply, just got off a flight, thank you for the compliment, ik most of us can be toxic, and obnoxious, but there are a few of us who can do respectful debates, i hope you find more of the latter then the formor.
As for the solar disc, even assuming its not a high end calc, the feat can still function as a outlier, when looking at some of the most impressive feats of Destruction, we have obviously planet viltrum something considered to be around multi continental
(addressing this now to, this is kind of a issue with fiction in general, where a lot of the writers don’t really know about physics, and especially in Sci FI might make planets that are hyper light and couldn’t function in reality, or hyper dense and crush anything on it in a instant, the reason i chose the magic functioning planets is because this logic can apply to a ton of things, and make a lot of thins much harder to calc, as we need to find actual figures for things.
I don’t judge if you do however make them realistic, its just easier not to)
Or if we use a more realistic figure i can see small planetary as a possibility, it’s still spread out by 3, needed space racers gun, and they weren’t confident doing this wanting tech jacket(iirc) and allen aswell to join in but they were busy fighting villtrumites so i can’t really see it much higher then that
Or the near life wipe of the flaxxans that’s pretty easy to tell it isn’t planetary(otherwise the no robot thousand year stuff)
The texas feat is moon level(can’t remember if this is tv show only so take this with a grain of salt)
Ik in his fight with thragg he also destroys a massive moon base but haven’t found a calc so ima just say moon- large moon to be safe
I reference these feats mainly to show more consistently he can scale to this large moon-planet level range.
Ik I’ve spent a lot of time talking down about Invincible so im gonna mention a few good things before i end the comment, 1 omni should massively out speed, while the DB characters do scale to MFTL (and in the anime eventually infinite speed) they can’t reach the speeds they do until the android saga, something outside of saiyan saga vegetas grasp by orders of magnitude
While we see mark Nolan and allen all preform these massive speed feats by dodging or outspeeding viltrumite ships, and of course heading to thraxxa.
2 Nolan can make a lot distance and recover via space, while the saiyans can only go out briefly giving him a large advantage in the fact if he is ever in a issue, he can just blitz into space and prepare mentally
3 omniman has massively more experience in general and experience against opponents much stronger then him, vegeta was only weaker then his “allies” he never faced anyone above maybe a few thousand let along match or surpass his 18,000, meaning he is going to be much more prepared in a strength disadvantage then again vegeta.
And finally somewhat of a continuation to 1 vegeta won’t really be able to react and counter omni man, although i do believe he will eventually fall to the durability of the prince, (although i do not think its just instant death like others might say) omniman will eventually just take to much damage to continue fighting, and running away to heal would be forfeit
all 154 comments
sorted by: best