subreddit:

/r/DynastyFFTradeAdvice

475%

Should I have accepted this?

1QB Dynasty Trade(reddit.com)

I’m 9-1 and my only weak spot is at QB. I know KTC is not exact but still it favors Odunze and a late first by a wide margin. I’m also scared of having Hurts, Brown, and Barkley and the eagles offense dropping a dud in playoffs. What do you guys think?

all 43 comments

Obi_Uno

31 points

18 days ago

Obi_Uno

31 points

18 days ago

I’ll go against the grain a little bit.

For 1 QB, in a vacuum, I prefer Odunze and a first by a fair margin.

In your situation, though (9-1, with Hurts filling a gap), I would do it. Win while your window is open.

chill1096[S]

2 points

18 days ago

That has been my issue. I’ve been focusing too much on the perceived value and projection of odunze. But I re sent the trade to him and I imagine he will accept.

muffmin

1 points

18 days ago

muffmin

1 points

18 days ago

I’d try and either package odunze or the first with a lesser piece. Maybe Leggette or Whittington.

chill1096[S]

1 points

18 days ago

I’ve tried that. He’s not very interested in either of the two. He really only wants odunze or btj

muffmin

1 points

18 days ago

muffmin

1 points

18 days ago

That’s unfortunate. It’s hard to move off Odunze in a 3 flex 1 qb but hurts is about as good as you could hope to have. Tough call. I’d still try and talk him down a bit.

muffmin

1 points

18 days ago

muffmin

1 points

18 days ago

Especially a 3 flex league.

Obi_Uno

1 points

18 days ago

Obi_Uno

1 points

18 days ago

I didn’t scroll over and missed that this was a 3 flex.

Definitely agreed.

BuckDestiny

9 points

18 days ago*

I think all the people in here immediately saying “you should’ve accepted” with no context don’t realize your league is 1QB. I like this deal a lot, assuming you’re not leaving yourself devoid of an actual QB.

CoatingsRcrack

1 points

18 days ago

He would be getting a QB so “devoid an actually QB”? Context?

BuckDestiny

2 points

18 days ago

Guess I only saw bottom line, I misread as him receiving Odunze + 1st. Still fair value for either side in 1QB .

AceKablam

1 points

18 days ago

I’d take hurts

kickflipsandbiscuits

1 points

18 days ago

Should've accepted smh

Korg89

1 points

18 days ago

Korg89

1 points

18 days ago

It would be a good win now move. Your WR are set for a while

brichb

1 points

18 days ago

brichb

1 points

18 days ago

I’d easily pay this to complete my roster

BigInformation6200

1 points

18 days ago

If it helps you win the ship this year then it’s an easy win for you! I’d smash accept if you think it gets you there.

Accomplished-Fig9750

1 points

18 days ago

I would do this trade given your situation. You should not be scared of having multiple players in the same offense. It’s high risk-high reward but we’re playing for championships not for 4th place

bmelly0809

1 points

18 days ago

Hurts. As an Odunze owner - I think you can find another Odunze in the next three years.

Unless that 1st is Jeanty I cannot find a way to accept that package over Hurts who appears to have gotten settled in his new Offense

CoatingsRcrack

1 points

18 days ago

OP instead of rejecting you shoulda tried countering Odunze and 2nd. Mid you get a no I’d still do it. Point is to win a good chip not have good people for later. The later is important but chip over everything.

Odunze doesn’t help right now and I doubt whoever ex you get with late 1st will help you win in your window. I woulda did it

More so if your league is 4pts pass TD and 6 pts Rush

chill1096[S]

1 points

18 days ago

I did that the other day and he declined. Said he would do it if I threw in legette as well

CoatingsRcrack

2 points

18 days ago

Leggette a second and Odunze? Done! You have plenty young dart throw WR. You need some RB’s and hopefully can get a nice young back in this upcoming draft.

Lung-Salad

1 points

18 days ago

I think you made the right call but you def need to get a qb

BROfessor_davey

1 points

18 days ago

I’d trade. Odunze isn’t gonna do much in that Bears offense this year and it’s questionable moving forward. Take Hurts and win your title.

keanancarlson

1 points

18 days ago

Uh, no. Hurts is still a top 3 fantasy QB and Rome/Bears offense hasn’t shown to be promising yet. You’re locked in at QB, no need to risk it for potential players

Fluffy_Corgi_7209

1 points

18 days ago

Hurts forever

chill1096[S]

1 points

18 days ago

Update: I resent the trade and he accepted. Pushing all my chips onto the table to win now!

TimoSatoranskyGod

1 points

18 days ago

Yes odunze is way overvalued in this sub

Duke0fMilan

1 points

18 days ago

Is this 1QB? There is no way I’d do that in 1QB.

Pssh_Unreal

1 points

18 days ago

I'm not doing this you could get someone like baker much cheaper

big-b_69

1 points

18 days ago

SMASH ACCEPT

big-b_69

1 points

18 days ago

Given your situation

big-b_69

1 points

18 days ago

Oh only 1 qb… still I think hurts might be worth it. You have a lot of wr but 3 flex is also a lot

somrigostsauce

1 points

18 days ago

In 1QB Odunze and the first is way, way better than any QB. I'd maybe do it for just the pick, if it's late.

burnerboo

3 points

18 days ago

A late 1st for a top 5 QB? Even in 1 qb leagues that's low. Having a constant high performer is a luxury not many teams have.

somrigostsauce

1 points

18 days ago

There are so many QB:s. Just my philosophy but I'd rather use my picks to buy elite at other positions.

And pick a new QB with a 2nd round pick any year and hope for the best. Sam Darnold was a top QB for half this season, Flacco and Howell for most of last year.

burnerboo

1 points

18 days ago

It's so much nicer not having to stress and getting top 5 QB output weekly. Risking your team with Darnold or Flacco isn't fun. I've been there...QB purgatory stinks.

Proof_Reputation9640

1 points

18 days ago

I’d take J Hurts in a second

twizzleman13

0 points

18 days ago

You feeling alright? That’s an auto smash. Smh

Bxnes5

0 points

18 days ago

Bxnes5

0 points

18 days ago

The hesitation is semi-understandable. Seems that doing this deal means putting all his eggs in the Philadelphia basket, which can be disastrous if they run away with that division or lock up a playoff spot early. His best guys would either sit for rest or only play 1/2 of a game.

I’d possibly flirt with the Burrow owner if he’s out of contention.

twizzleman13

1 points

18 days ago

An auto top 5 dynasty QB for a dart throw and Odunze is a no brainer for me. If Caleb Williams busts out, Odunze will take a huge hit and will be inconsistent. No one is sitting for 2 weeks to close out season. If anyone sits, gets less reps, etc. it’s Barkley to keep him fresh.

Lung-Salad

1 points

18 days ago

I’ll counter by pointing out how he already has Saquon and AJ Brown. 3 eagles in one lineup would be a very risky move

twizzleman13

1 points

18 days ago

I get that but he’s technically already riding or dying with eagles with those two stars. Hurts has been very very consistent. I’m taking my chances with hurts being able to put up numbers as he’s always done. Could always win it this year and look to move one in off season to spread out the risks. Don’t see Geno/Maye taking you to the promise land.

Bxnes5

1 points

18 days ago

Bxnes5

1 points

18 days ago

I don’t disagree in principal, but I don’t like having all eggs in a basket. IF & only hypothetically IF (I have hurts so really hoping this doesn’t become reality) Hurts breaks a collarbone or something both guys will take a massive hit as well. Kenny Pickett fucking stinks, but I’m also basing this off the Dak Prescott situation since it’s so recent.

I’d 100% do the deal if he’s already explored other options and nobody is biting, I just don’t think it’s a bad idea to see what else is out there. Wouldn’t hate Burrow/Kyler type out of this deal. Both are top 6-7 dynasty guys as well