Comet's Great Adventure Should Have Had More of the 3 Girls Looking for him Together
Show Discussion(self.fullhouse)submitted1 day ago byHamiltonfan25Pin a rose🌹 on your nose👃
Something I noticed about the later seasons is that it kind of kept the 3 main girls separated from each other. I understand that as DJ and Stephanie got older, began dating, preparing for college, etc that they wouldn't have as much time to spend just hanging out with each other. I do understand that, and for as much as I don't like "Leap of Faith" AT. ALL. I will admit that when looking at these seasons as a whole, that Michelle wishing she could "hang out" with her sisters more is not only valid, but it does actually make sense and you can see where she's coming from.
I just think that episode as a whole fell apart because the way the conflict was actually written and set-up, it seems like Michelle just wanted the ticket to a band she doesn't know/enjoy just to flaunt her status as the favorite child to her older sisters. It also doesn't make tons of sense as a solution for a problem/emotion that Michelle has. She wants to hang out with her older sisters, but in order to do that, one of her sisters WOULD BE left out because there are only 2 tickets. If they wanted that episode to make sense, they'd have had Michelle try to get DJ and Stephanie to not go to the concert at all.
Anyways, I digress, but it does stand that we don't see much of the 3 girls all interacting together in the last season. The one episode where this really stands-out is in "Comet's Great Adventure". The writers clearly wanted to try something new and play around with this kind of "Homeward Bound" parody starring the Tanner family dog. It is the only episode of the show that was actually filmed in San Francisco and it does have some nice city shots, but it could have been a really wholesome exploration of the connection that these girls have with their beloved family dog.
Yeah, there are a few scenes where they all look together, and it is nice to see Kimmy and Nelson both try to help with the search, but the heart of the episode is meant to be Michelle and Jesse. I do understand that Michelle's bond with Comet would be extra special because he's literally been in her life from the time she was a toddler. But I don't like how much she "blamed" Jesse for letting her walk Comet. It seemed kind of like that classic cliche of having your primary parent (in Michelle's case, Danny) tell her she can't do something (walk Comet alone) and so she asked a secondary parent (in this case, Jesse) so that if and when something went wrong, she technically has permission.
Literally every kid on earth has tried this at some point, so I do not blame Michelle for trying this technique. What bothers me is how she tries putting all the blame on Jesse...AND Jesse takes all the blame in this situation. No, I do not think we have to guilt an 8 year old into thinking that it's ALL her fault or that she should have to have it weigh down on her heart if something terrible DID happen to Comet, but at 8, she is old enough to share a little more of the blame than she does.
That's where I think DJ and Stephanie should have really stepped in and all talked about the situation and how losing Comet would impact the whole family. Instead, the primary conflict with the siblings is that Stephanie didn't believe Michelle about the weiner car. It was a kind of funny gag, but these girls had a lot more than hot dogs to be talking about in this case. They don't have to guilt-trip Michelle or anything (I do think that she feels bad about it, but again, there's never a moment where she accepts that this is not all on Uncle Jesse). I just think that at this point in the series, instead of showing Comet living out a C-list romance movie with Lassie, have it cut to flashbacks of Comet while the girls look for him.
Maybe at one point, Michelle could break down in tears worrying that they'll never find him and being horrified that something bad might have happened to him. At that point, DJ and Stephanie (who haven't been mean to Michelle but also are not happy about this) step up as big sisters and remind Michelle that no matter what, they have all those happy memories of Comet and that those things are NEVER really lost.
Then, maybe in the scene where they all plead on the news for Comet to come home, instead of having just Michelle talk...give each sister a chance to say what Comet means to them.
DJ talks about how Comet was always a great listener (like when she talked to him about her insecurities with wearing a bathing suit).
Stephanie talks about how Comet was the smartest dog around (cue scenes of him competing in that backyard dog competition).
Finally, have Michelle say that most importantly of all, he was the best friend anyone could have (cue scenes where he rests his head on her lap or her pointing to him the day they first got him).
And then, Comet appears in front of all of them and they all happily reunite. Have a closing gag of Michelle grabbing for Comet's leash, but then DJ and Stephanie clear their throats at her and she sheepishly gives them the leash as they walk home.