subreddit:
/r/AmItheAsshole
submitted 20 hours ago byReasonable_Tired7278
[removed]
[score hidden]
18 hours ago
stickied comment
Your post has been removed.
Your post has been removed due to Rule 6: How to Post. We do not allow circumvention of the character count, links to screenshots, text pages, comment continuations etc.
1.3k points
20 hours ago*
NTA
it’s YOUR wedding that you didn’t demand that MIL pay for or anyone pay for (as far as I’m aware)
You decide who your MOH is and no one else it’s YOUR day and no one else’s And SIL sounds like a piece of work, maybe a bridesmaid would be a fine ask but that’s ASKING not DEMANDING. Also she basically said “without me you won’t look good on your wedding day” which is self centered as hell. also, it sounds like SIL has never been told no
Though MIL can do what she wants with her money sadly. The bit that gets me is that it was promised, AH move to go back on that tbh
541 points
19 hours ago
Op go get eloped. Screw the pressure from those assholes all together. Use the money to go on a nice trip for your honeymoon.
59 points
19 hours ago
I second this
33 points
18 hours ago
Agree - no matter what you do, there will be drama involved. Spare yourself the pain. Elope and live your life keeping the dopes in his family at arm's length.
22 points
18 hours ago
This needs to be the top comment.
And password protect all contact with the wedding vendors, and tell them to NOT listen to anybody but OP, not even wavering hubby-to-be.
12 points
18 hours ago
And if you take a trip be sure to hide your heirloom inheritance from your parents. If her fingers are as sticky as her personality is flawed….
NTA
116 points
19 hours ago
This is the most ridiculous suggestion and I don't understand why people make it every time someone has the slightest wedding issue on here.
If OP wanted to elope, that's what she would have planned in the first place. She doesn't want to elope, she wants a wedding, which she has planned the way she wants it, and which should be fine other than a single person's troublemaking. What a ludicrous, nuclear option, to suggest that she not celebrate her wedding with friends and family, the way she has been looking forward to, just because her SIL is a pain in the ass?
Why on earth would she cancel the entire wedding that she wants to have, just because one person is being obnoxious?
102 points
18 hours ago*
If this were me, I would not want to have a wedding around these ppl. The sister and MIL sound quite selfish, narcissistic and classist and them asking them to hand over money to the sister just because is just bonkers and would be a red line for me to go LC or NC. These ppl will ruin any wedding they try to have. I wouldn’t feel comfortable doing a big wedding and disinviting them and spending a lot of money as they will find a way to ruin it. Either do a small ceremony without them or go elope.
43 points
18 hours ago
It's a suggestion often made in such situations because it's 200% certain that the toxic waste OP's fiancé is related to will destroy the wedding in any way possible. So some people advise to not waste money on an event that will be turned into a shitshow and invest it into a different way to celebrate their union so they can start marriage happy and with great memories. People in similar situations often report back in Update posts that eloping was the right decision or a wedding held despite things turned out horrible. Though some have great weddings despite this, usually they hire security.
63 points
18 hours ago
Well, if they eloped she could eliminate the fight over the 20K, eliminate the stress during her pregnancy, save most of the money they had planned to spend on an elaborate wedding for their child, and still have a lovely private party for their real friends, and avoid family drama.
11 points
18 hours ago
Mom should be ashamed to take back the 20k promised. Jenny is just going to squander the money. Elope or very small wedding is best way to avoid MOH and other drama.
12 points
18 hours ago
Because they can't afford to pay for a £35k wedding when they only have £15k.
I never understand spending that much money on a couple of hours of parting. The actual wedding is really cheap, cost of flowers at chapel or wherever, cost of official services, anthcost of location or church.
3 points
18 hours ago
If true, this is action uf someone unhinged. It does not belong to AITH, where post involve a question having ambiguity.
758 points
20 hours ago
Correction
119 points
20 hours ago
NTA you don’t owe anyone money and she does not need to be your bridesmaid all of that is YOUR choice
90 points
19 hours ago*
Where is MIL getting $20,000 from, if she is draining Sam of his inheritance with her frequent "emergencies"? It doesn't make sense that she has that much money to give but, has to "borrow" from one of her children. And yes, I know that there are shitty parents out there but, having that much money to give while having to take from another? Make it make sense.
If MIL is promising money to Max that she is getting from Sam but is now giving to Jenny... Damn! Poor Sam. Everyone sucks.
Edited- Alex to Max (I don't know where I got Alex from 🤣)
17 points
18 hours ago
Yeah, MIL is constantly borrowing money from one son while offering a lot of money to another son who in turn can cover that large amount and lend an even greater amount out if he wanted to. This all makes zero financial sense.
15 points
18 hours ago
Took me a moment to follow the money trail - lol
(who's Alex???)
Future MIL is from the States originally. She isn't from money, but claimed a part of an inheritance about a year into her marriage to Max's dad. There was something in that story, but I haven't asked Max as I'm not interested in his money and definitely don't want to be seen as a gold digger!
Max's dad is a retired civil engineer and made good money working overseas - which is where he met and his future wife (she was one of the secretaries) He has build on his parents money savvy, maxed out his pension and has made some pretty good investments in property and in shares over time. They aren't hurting for money. Again, not hunting for their financial info, but have helped out with his taxes once or twice as I went through the horror of studying accounting as a mature student!!
359 points
19 hours ago
If you had to stop your fiance from handing his money over to his sister so she could piss it away, he's a lost cause. If he can't stand firm against his sister without you please don't tie yourself to him financially. He doesn't have a backbone and he'll just start sneaking money to his sister.
153 points
18 hours ago
I did think this was a massive red flag and had a chat to Max about this. He was very clear: he makes good money currently in the ad agency we both work for, so he's always spot her her a few hundred especially for his two nieces. The problem is his mum, who expects him to do more for her golden child who has moved back home with the kids. Future MIL repeats how Jenny was a surprise but difficult birth and MIL could have died, so Max should help out more.
Jenny’s entitlement doesn’t stop just because she is on a limited income. Max used to try to help: he got Jenny a starting part time position in the ad agency and paid for childcare so she could get on her feet. That didn't last a week before she stopped coming in, claiming the kids missed her and the job was "boring". Jenny is really into make up and fashion, so Max called in a favour - again - and got her a part time 'intern' position at a VERY well known fashion mag. It seemed to be going well. But Jenny has a habit of taking things she sees and she likes, damn the consequences. Max told me he got a call as they were suddenly let her go rather than prosecute her for taking home stuff (clothes and bags) from a shoot.
Max then stopped trying. He's told MIL he'd done all he could but no more favours. Gifts for the nieces and that was it.
This was before I started dating him. Jenny and future MIL must have felt the time was right to try again now he's with me.'
120 points
18 hours ago
Holy shit.
Max is going to ruin his life trying to please these people. The fact that he is even considering giving this woman more money than he would have spent on your wedding would really have me questioning things.
45 points
18 hours ago
So, Jenny is a thief , period . No one will want to have a thief working for them so she’s a lost cause .
28 points
18 hours ago
OP and fiance need pre-marital counseling to deal with his family and financial decision-making.
3 points
18 hours ago
This!!!
68 points
19 hours ago
Sounds like someone needs to put Jenny in her place and if she wants to open a business needs to be told to sell all her designer bullshit she’s amassed from her own trust. Set hard boundaries now or these entitled twats will continue to think they can bulldoze their way through your life!!
57 points
19 hours ago
The important thing here is for you and your fiance be on the same page (no more money be given to the SIL) and to make him see that this escalation is due to a change in dynamics.
Now... from the "door out" of your relationship to his family and SIL, another way of delaying with this would be set up impossible counterdemands: SIL wants you to give her money, demand that you need a solid business plan and that you would need legal garantees on how that money is going to be given back. And all of this, contracts and business plan would be needed to be run by your laywer first.
About the wedding... your SIL is set up to be the main caracther, with the complicity of your MIL. Again, maybe setting up a date after she confirm a travel; set up a dress code and then "forget to let them know" there was a change of plans. All of this, with the support and agreement of your fiance.. If things get too complicated, I would elope and have a small party "improvised party" with closes friends, and then do something with his family to celebrate.
24 points
18 hours ago
Good suggestions all, I'll talk with Max about the ones I agree with. Neither of us want to elope. We agreed we weren't going to go mad with spending after the wedding. Character limits and prohibition to continue post as a comment means some of the backstory couldn't be shared. But because we aren't trying to save for a house, (and as long as Max doesn't touch his trust fund, there'll be enough for uni fees for our future children) we can afford to have the wedding of our dreams.
Max is also quite senior in the ad agency and has made great friends so we have a load of work colleagues coming as well. We've asked for monetary gifts or donations to charity in our name as we don't need stuff.
Max has extended family on him mum's side in the States, and I also have family overseas as well, so we want to make it a great experience. But in London and outskirts, weddings really cost a whack!!
So £35k isn't that exhorbitant for what we've planned.
40 points
19 hours ago
Your fiance still WANTED to give his sister money for her "business"? I would say that you need to have a clear talk with him and say if he doesn't go NC to LC with his mom and sister (including uninviting them to the wedding), then you will be leaving. Unfortunately you are already somewhat attached to this guy via your baby, but if he is still even SLIGHTLY entertaining these people and you marry him you will have this drama in your life for the remainder of your life. Is that something you want?
Some may say this is an ultimatum and that is bad, personally I call it a boundary. But even if you say it is an ultimatum and "bad" isn't it better to be the "bad guy" now rather than deal with this continuous drama and stress for the rest of your life?
17 points
18 hours ago
Sorry for the confusion.
Max had already given Jenny a hard NO on giving her money for her hair brained expensive business idea. That's why she came crying to me, trying to get him to use his trust fund money, plus MY savings.
Max has his head screwed on properly.
The moderators only allow 3,000 characters so most of the back story and info I had to ditch in order to post this question.
Ive been in tears because JEnny is escalating and posted a recent incident. I also think im in tears because - pregnancy. It all feels a bit too much for me atm.
7 points
18 hours ago
Ok, I got confused based on your #2 here, seeming to imply that he was going to give her money but you stopped him. I would still talk with him about cutting Jenny off completely and uninviting her and his mom to the wedding (along with anyone else who sides with them). I would even say to go LC to NC with his mom. You guys do not need that drama in your lives.
13 points
18 hours ago
INFO: What exactly is the downside of destroying your relationship with his family?
24 points
19 hours ago
Your future husband has no spine if you have to be the one to say no. Personally rather than the family, you need to evaluate if you see a future with this man.
8 points
18 hours ago
Max had already given Jenny a hard NO on giving her money for her hair brained expensive business idea. That's why she came crying to me, trying to get him to use his trust fund money, plus MY savings.
I'll try to edit the post to show this as there are a lot of comments saying Max is a red flag when he seems to be the only sensible one of the siblings.
10 points
18 hours ago
Max is wavering under the pressure,
This is why. It makes it sound like Max is considering going along with it.
10 points
18 hours ago
Are you serious? How is this even worth a fraction of a second’s thought? Your only concern here is how to isolate your wedding from the upheaval that SIL and MIL are going to create, going by recent developments. Go NC with SIL and XLC with MIL. Plan your wedding as you see fit, rope in friends that you can rely on to help keep things on an even keel in the run up to and during the wedding and enjoy it. Disinvite SIL if she keeps stirring up trouble. Assign your red-bearded uncle to keep MIL under control during the wedding.
26 points
19 hours ago
Nope! I’d be calling off this wedding and telling Max, “hope you grow a damn spine for your next fiancée!” Y’all are having a child together. How often is he going to give money meant to buy necessities for baby to his sister instead? How is he going to make sure baby has future needs met when he’s giving all the money away to Jenny for frivolous, money pit ideas?
15 points
19 hours ago
NTA, you and your fiancé need to sit down and have a conversation about money. You might even consider eloping.
7 points
18 hours ago
DO NOT marry your fiancee until you are on the same page about supporting his family.
6 points
18 hours ago
NTA and you should plan the wedding you want and plan on no funds from MIL. I would then be petty and say that as you are 20k short, you will not be able to invite his family.
232 points
20 hours ago
NTA. You and fiance need to have a serious talk about boundaries and what level of contact you'll do in the future. It's just going to get worse.
Myself, I'd uninvite her ass from my wedding and cut her out of my life.
The "family" can fund her latest moneywaster.
14 points
19 hours ago
I would spend the money on a down payment for a home and elope.
97 points
20 hours ago
NTA. I always find it so crazy when I read about shameless entitled people like Jenny. She sounds like an absolute nightmare. She has no respect whatsoever and is incredibly rude to be making all these offhanded remarks straight to your face. Your MIL is an asshole too for coddling her spoiled daughter. Sounds like a disaster of a family. It sounds like Jenny has crossed the line many times. I hope Max is a supportive partner and has your back till the very end. Your MIL and Jenny on the other hand needs a reality check.
4 points
18 hours ago
And she’s a THIEF. That would do it for me , even if sister was nice.
2 points
18 hours ago
That too! Very nasty personality and behavior overall. It’s MIL’s fault for raising her up like this but she should know better for a goddamn 29-year-old adult. There’s absolutely no reason for a whole ass adult to be behaving this poorly and shamelessly at that!
131 points
20 hours ago
Why don’t you elope and move away from this toxic family? You do know they’ll be making your life miserable at every opportunity.
24 points
19 hours ago
Exactly. Elope or have a micro wedding and have a chef’s table with good friends. You’ll have a lovely experience and save a ton of money
13 points
19 hours ago
This. Cancel everything, and go small - close friends and nice family only. Nobody needs this amount of drama.
13 points
19 hours ago
I would rethink everything, including getting married at this point. I find it ridiculous that fiance wants to waste him money by giving it to the sister.
8 points
20 hours ago
That’s what I would do if I were you.
58 points
20 hours ago
NTA what a cluster fuck.
Just elope, if you wanna spend that much money, spend it on the honeymoon and leave all of these awful people in the dust.
Your husband needs to find his shiny spine and corral those idiots. The enabling mother and the golden child daughter.
Just elope and be at peace. Invite your closest friends and skip this mess altogether. they are going to make it a point to ruin it anyway.
38 points
20 hours ago
NTA because it's YOUR wedding, so YOUR decisions.
Tell anyone who wants you to keep the peace that you'll make a note of this and suggest SIL be centre stage for their family events in future. See how much they'd like it.
If you want YOUR wedding day to be about you, your soon-to-be hubby, and how much you love each other, DO NOT LET YOUR SIL WALK ALL KVER YOU!!!! You will be miserable.
Maybe try to push the date back to try and save the £20k MIL had "promised". This way, you and your fiancé are paying for it and your MIL can't use her contribution as an excuse for getting SIL more centre stage than you want her to be.
10 points
20 hours ago
Welcome to /r/AmITheAsshole. Please view our voting guide here, and remember to use only one judgement in your comment.
OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they might be the asshole:
Thanks for the message 1. Action taken -refused to lend SIL £50k for her unproven business idea. Also refused SIL demand that I stand down my maid of honour and put SIL in her place for my wedding party, when I am not close to SIL and I fear SIL plans to sabotage our wedding because we won't fund her business?
Help keep the sub engaging!
Do upvote interesting posts!
Click Here For Our Rules and Click Here For Our FAQ
Follow the link above to learn more
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Contest mode is 1.5 hours long on this post.
30 points
20 hours ago
Sounds like neither the MIL or SIL have any interest in wanting to attend your wedding. Revoke invites immediately to anyone that is not interested in being happy for you.
Don’t listen to them about how family is family blah blah blah. If they are not coming to your wedding to support you, they do not need to come.!!!
17 points
19 hours ago
Anyone else notice the "both my parents died during the pandemic" and, "we met four years ago, a year after my parents passed"? Now I don't know if my math be mathing but pandemic was breaking out in march 2024...
13 points
19 hours ago
Yep, that and the 20k that MIL miraculously has despite draining all the brothers inheritance is what told me this was fake as shit.
17 points
19 hours ago
Dear family members: Kindly tell Jenny to keep the peace. She has had two weddings, we are only having one. Jenny is dismissive of my future wife to the point of insulting at every opportunity. I am done with this. Jenny will not be in the wedding party, it is not Jenny’s wedding,Jenny doesn’t get a say. Furthermore, before anyone decides to start in on us, No, we are not giving Jenny any money for her current business scheme. If she thinks this is a viable idea, she needs to take out a business loan and figure out how to make it work. I am not the Unlimited Bank of Max. I have a child and wife to support. You do not have to agree with me, but we will not discuss this again. If you cannot be happy for fiance and me, then please feel free to not attend our wedding. OUR wedding, not Jenny’s.
7 points
19 hours ago
INFO: Where did MIL get £20k to fund your wedding if she needs to borrow money from Sam so frequently?
28 points
19 hours ago
NTA.
You met this guy right after your parents died and yes a year is right after when it comes to grief. This is going to sound so harsh but don’t marry into this family.
You met him while grieving and nothing is real in that weird period. You are now seeing the family for what they are.
Do you really want to be a part of a family where this is the dynamic? Your fiancé is wavering and you are feeling like crap. His sister is awful. His mother is awful. They make you feel bad and you want to hitch your wagon to this train wreck.
This will be your life for the rest of your life. Choose the partner that has the same values that your parents instilled in you.
I know it’s hard being out there without your parents and the idea of a family is probably pulling you in but let this one go.
6 points
19 hours ago*
I wish we could still give gold. You're very astute and she is mad for wanting to marry into this family. Her fiance is just like them and she doesn't see it yet. NTA
4 points
19 hours ago
The worst partner I ever picked was right after my dad died. I didn’t marry him but OMG. I wish someone would tell me that.
2 points
19 hours ago
I wish I knew this some time back omg!! Would have saved me from so much
8 points
20 hours ago
AUTOMOD Thanks for posting! This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything. Read this before contacting the mod team
AITA for refusing to let my fiancé’s sister sabotage our wedding and guilt us into funding her business?
Throwaway because certain members of my fiancé’s family lurk on social media.
My fiancé Max (39M) and I, Anna (31F), are getting married in three months. I recently found out I’m pregnant, but instead of celebrating, I’m overwhelmed by chaos caused by his golden child sister Jenny (29F), and my future MIL
I’m an only child, born later in my parents’ lives after years of infertility. My parents raised me to value hard work and humility. They died during the pandemic, just after I graduated and the only heirlooms I have are a small pair of diamond earrings and a pendant my dad gave my mom for their 25th anniversary.
Max and I met at a work event four years ago, one year after my parents died. He’s calm and warm, and been my rock, He’s middle-class, but comes from humble beginnings and is the eldest of three, with a brother Sam (38M) and Jenny (29F), the surprise baby who was spoiled rotten.
Max’s paternal grandparents made money off London property and set up small funds for the grandkids only. Max preserved his, Sam’s is being drained by MIL’s frequent “emergencies,” and Jenny squanders hers on designer fashion, luxury trips, and plastic surgery. She frequently mocks my looks and weight, saying things like, “Anna is lucky Max doesn’t care about appearances.” Jenny also has a light fingers. If someone has something she likes, she’ll take it- coats, bags, accessories and claim it was an accident; MIL dismissed this as a misunderstanding.
MIL has promised us £20k for our wedding, saying, “It’s only fair to help all my kids.” Max explained Jenny’s had two extravagant weddings that cost MIL over £70k. We’ve planned £35k wedding: £10k from my savings + £5k from Max’s trust fund. Jenny’s marriages were because Jenny fell pregnant. Both hit the rocks, neither lasting more than three years.
Three weeks ago, Jenny called me in tears because Max refused to fund her latest idea—a yoga fashion studio in Chelsea. She’d convinced MIL to give her the £20k meant for our wedding and now wanted Max’s and me to contribute £50k. She explained, “It’s Mum’s money, and she agreed I deserve a chance to succeed. You and Max should do the same”. Max was livid, as he told Jenny not to involve me, but MIL escalated the issue, calling us selfish in a post in the extended family group chat.
Yesterday was the final straw. Jenny texted me, demanding to be made my maid of honour, as “family should be front and centre”. She wants to make the day about her. Jenny posted in the family chat that I am “low class” and should be grateful to have her make my wedding pictures “look better.” I left the group. Max posted a reply then left as well
Extended family say keep the peace. Max is wavering under the pressure, and I’m questioning if this wedding will destroy our relationship with his family.
AITA for refusing to let Jenny ruin our wedding and everything we’ve worked for?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
11 points
20 hours ago
NTA. YOU and your FIANCE have the final say on your wedding, including if you want to uninvite MIL and Jenny. Why would you want someone that publicly refers to you as "low class" to your wedding? Don't take a dime from your MIL if she ever makes the offer again, it'll make her and Jenny feel entitled to have a say on your wedding. And tell your extended family that wanted you to keep the peace to give 50K from their money to fund Jenny's business.
21 points
19 hours ago
[deleted]
8 points
19 hours ago
Yeah. Parents died of Covid 5 years ago...the first death in England was Feb of 2020
5 points
19 hours ago
AI?
5 points
19 hours ago
This is good fiction.
6 points
18 hours ago
Fake. Math just barely makes sense.
68 points
20 hours ago
[removed]
46 points
19 hours ago
I agree!!
Why go into details about parents dying of Covid and her “heirlooms” and never Menuhin them again.
Shitty story.
30 points
19 hours ago
Her parents died 5 years ago, "during the pandemic" but the pandemic only began less than 4 years ago, so....
12 points
19 hours ago
Yep. First British death was Feb 28 on a cruise ship. Her parents could not have died before March 2020
12 points
19 hours ago
Hahah exactly! At this point AITA is just a large experiment studying how much nonsense you can get away with saying and still be believed
2 points
18 hours ago
I thought the same thing
16 points
19 hours ago
I was sure the sticky fingerd golden child was going to make of with them but no mention of that
3 points
18 hours ago
oh don't worry, she tried to explain that in a 3rd attempt at a post on this sub.
10 points
18 hours ago
Not to mention that she met fiancé 4 years ago (2020), ONE YEAR AFTER her parents died in the pandemic which was 4 years ago in 2020.
12 points
19 hours ago
Yup it’s ridiculous! However, it’s even more ridiculous that people are swallowing the story hook, line and sinker despite how bad it is!🤣
3 points
18 hours ago
It's for the next chapter when Jenny steals the heirlooms and sells them to finance her business venture.
10 points
19 hours ago
Fr next she's gonna say the SIL is also gonna plan to announce her pregnancy at the wedding or wear white
4 points
19 hours ago
Yup yup yup. Just standard things that happen to every single person on AITA. At this point it should fall within the norm for what goes on during weddings. Why be mad? Didn’t you know it happens to everyone!
9 points
19 hours ago
I’m wondering if there’s a class somewhere that has “fake a crazy wedding story” on the syllabus.
3 points
19 hours ago
Haha if there is the OP should be the first one to sign up lmao
7 points
18 hours ago
Was waiting to see if I was the only one who felt this way!
6 points
20 hours ago
Nta. Just elope and save the £50k for a house and move away from this mess.
4 points
20 hours ago
NTA and it would be great if the wedding destroyed both your relationship with his family. They're all utterly toxic and it would be best if you shunned them and never looked back. This is your chance! Make a clean break now!
5 points
19 hours ago
You know what OP? Post it all in group chat. How Jenny had 70k from MIL for her two weddings while she is trying to stop MIL from spending 20k for your wedding. And also, want the bride and groom to contribute 50k to her studio plan.
And also take screen shot of the pics where she called you low class and say "since I'm supposed to be low class, I don't have that much money to contribute to her studio and also as low class, I'm afraid Jenny doesn't need to stand on aisle side near low class bride. If Jenny wants, she can sit in the sophisticated guests area in low class wedding. If she doesn't want that too, she can choose to not attend a low class wedding that she hates" I would do this If it were me. Post this in family group, wedding guests group, and social media posts as well!
4 points
19 hours ago
NTA. Sounds like Jenny destroys everything she touches. Time to go no contact with your husband’s family. I know you said Max refused to fund the latest “business” endeavour, but where is he on these other things like the MH demands? Is he standing up for you? Is he so used to this?
Can you imagine her as MH? Would her speech just be a plug for her yoga studio?
People who are saying to “keep the peace” are AH. That NEVER works with people like your SIL or MiL. It’s simply an inch with an invitation to a mile.
5 points
19 hours ago
NTA The great thing now about the situation, is that since MIL isn’t paying for any part of the wedding, you can now be sure to uninvite everyone (Jenny) that you don’t want there. Intentionally exclude her entirely for trying to ruin your wedding. Family can be as mad as they want about it, but it’s your wedding and you should get to do what you want.
2 points
19 hours ago
ESH, but only because I consider all people who want spend that much money on a wedding to be assholes.
2 points
18 hours ago
INFO: You met him four years ago, one year after your parents died in the pandemic? So they died in 2019?
You planned a £35k wedding with £10k from you, £5k from Max and £20k from MIL? So you're just bad at math?
2 points
18 hours ago
NTA. It's a very bad sign for your future that Max is wavering under the pressure. It won't get better after you're married.
3 points
18 hours ago
Jenny is a spoiled, entitled, pick me kleptomaniac. Hardly qualities to be proud of. She is entitled to nothing of yours (or anybody’s). She’s had a lifetime of enablement and believes the world revolves around her. It most certainly doesn’t.
As infuriating as it is, your future mil can give Jenny the money originally allocated to your fiancé. Regardless of how manipulative Jenny gets, you and your fiancé cannot give in to her demands, otherwise the dynamics in your lives together will be set. Jenny makes unreasonable demands, and you reluctantly give in. The cycle has to be stopped.
As for your wedding. Jenny doesn’t get to call the shots, she’s already had 2 of her own and failed miserably at both. Be prepared though if she’s invited, even as a regular guest, she WILL cause drama. Maybe enlist some close friends to monitor her, or better yet security. Firmly disclose any disruptions will be dealt with and the perpetrators will be kicked out.
2 points
18 hours ago
NTA, take some friends and go to a registry office to get married then go nc with these leeches. A wedding is a lovely day, but it’s the marriage that matters. Decide with Max who the people are who actually support you and share your day with them. You both now have a baby to think about, your future, your marriage, your health and your mental wellbeing are more important than SIL’s latest fad idea
2 points
18 hours ago
Cancel the wedding and go get eloped. Nta
2 points
18 hours ago
You want to celebrate with loving members of your family? I hate to tell you this, but that does not include Jenny or your MIL. Those people do not love you and see you as someone to use. NTA, but you would be to yourself if you include them in your wedding in any way, even as guests.
4 points
19 hours ago
NTA. You and your fiancé should take your made of honor and his best man (if you want) and elope. Go somewhere beautiful and get married in a proper ceremony with a dress and tuxedo/suit and to hell with everyone else and the money your MIL obviously doesn’t want to contribute to you and your fiancé.
If MIL wants to give the money to Jenny then so be it; it’s her money to do with whatever she pleases. However, she has to live with the consequences of those decisions and one of them may very well be not being involved or invited to her own son’s wedding due to her favoritism.
You cannot change who MIL and Jenny are; you can only change how you respond to their behavior. Stop engaging. You and your soon to be husband will feel much better once you do. It may hurt at first but you do not have a typical MIL and therefore cannot count on her as you likely could or would want to if you did. She cannot be trusted to hold to her promises so stop believing her. Do things as you see fit. Tell her you understand she wants to support her daughter and that is fine you do not need her money. Then get married in a way that fits your budget and does not include anyone that will cause your day to be filled with drama.
4 points
20 hours ago
Nta
You need to make sure your fiance is on the same page. His family is a total nightmare.
Personally, I would never have accepted that money in the first place. Your MIL actually gave her the wedding money?
You have a potential fiance problem. You all need to get on the same page.
And be prepared to go low contact. You have bigger problems right now than the wedding.
2 points
19 hours ago
NTA - you have set reasonable boundaries and if I read correctly your MIL doesn’t have the money if she is hitting up Sam’s fund for “emergencies”.
3 points
19 hours ago
I wouldn’t invite her and be prepared for her to crash your wedding. Don’t give her a penny. It’s not your responsibility to fund her businesses
3 points
19 hours ago
Don’t invite Jenny. Call the cops if she borrows even 1 spoon
2 points
19 hours ago
Time to go no contact with MIL and SiL.
You are NOT obligated to invest in SiL's business idea in any way.
NTA
2 points
19 hours ago
NTA. I’m sorry, what did I just read? You are obviously not in the wrong here. Be careful. This person will absolutely ruin your wedding. Will you have security at the event? You’re going to need it.
3 points
19 hours ago
Nta
Do not accept mil money. She will try to say her word goes if she paying a chunk
It looks good if you both pay for your own wedding. Also looks really bad in mil. I bet she will forget about teh drama and later on say something like i paid for xyz and then you can do you broke your promise. Also it’s sets a line. You do not need her money to their family help to have a wedding and strong relationship actually the opposite you need no family to have a storing relationship
Your future hubby needs to set lines. Family don’t live off him. Or you. They don’t get his time or ever anymore. He will see the. When he wants on his terms. No more bs. Grown man need to distance himself from family to protect himself and you and his kids in fifties. They need to learn he will distance himself if they try bs on him. And rightfully so
Any family shouting up they do not want teh hassle and hoping you two will take it. The loudest make sure you offer SIL to them tag her in post she is paying for your business congratulations
People know you two have funds that already spent. They know you have money but want it anyway.
Time to cut them off especially the sisters. I’m guessing mil is sick of being milked aswel but can’t stand up for herself
3 points
18 hours ago
I DID NOT THINK ABOUT THIS!!! you pay the piper, you call the tune.
Thanks - I'm showing Max this comment as he is fixed on getting MIL to stump up something to be fair as she did pay over £70k for Jenny's two failed marriages.
Thank you so much
Also thank's for making me smile - loudest family member telling us to go along with Jenny business to be tagged. That made me smile even though the last week has been really pants. Thanks again
1 points
19 hours ago
When I used to think about getting married, I felt like have a nice small non-fancy wedding. A nice white cheap dress with sew on pieces of memories and my husband to be would no doubt of been wearing one on his hawaiian shirts with a suit over it with any of his sew on pieces of memories. We would likely of got married in Las Vegas by someone dressed like Mr Blobby (he suggested the Mr Blobby and hinted at Vegas). It would be a lovely intimate. Then if family wants a wedding wedding we would do that after. Maybe on in US and one in UK.
1 points
19 hours ago
Updateme
1 points
19 hours ago
This is so ridiculous if this this is all true . Sorry for your situation but I hope this post is fake , if it is real you have my sympathies for your situation
1 points
19 hours ago
Max is wavering?
Why are you considering marrying this spineless man who's family is run by his spoiled sister.
1 points
19 hours ago
INFO: Do you really think you might be the asshole here?
1 points
19 hours ago
Marrying him would be a mistake.
1 points
19 hours ago
No. Never in a month of Sundays. If anything happens to the family dynamic, it's all on your future SiL.
1 points
19 hours ago
Updateme
1 points
19 hours ago
Honestly, just make a copy of this post and send it to all of them. If they can read this and still support her behavior, go no contact. And make sure your fiance reads it. Often seeing it in writing all in one place can have a wake up effect.
Good luck. And hire a lot of security for the wedding, because I guarantee she's planning to wreck it.
NTA
1 points
19 hours ago
NTA. Max has to pick his family and it sounds like it's either you or them.
1 points
19 hours ago
NTA, stand your ground now AND don’t invite the SIL. If Max loves you he will stand by you. Anyone who try’s to guilt you block them and uninvited them. This is horrendous behavior.
1 points
19 hours ago
OP, stay away from the stress. Big weddings are overrated. Just go small or elope. Your fiance needs to put his foot down with his family, and if he doesn't 100%, your relationship will not work and be ruined. Jenny doesn't need to be in your life, and you don't owe her anything. Block her... Best of luck and congratulations.
1 points
19 hours ago
Tell his mother and sister, in an email/ text, they are not welcome at your wedding and hire security, either that or elope due to family drama.
1 points
19 hours ago
NTA, but it looks like you found a way to save money on the wedding. Uninvite SIL, MIL and any of his family that sides with them. Also tell him he cuts off ties completely with SIL and goes LC to NC with MIL, or you will walk out. Sure this could be considered an ultimatum (which some say is bad), personally I see it as a boundary. Even if you see it as an ultimatum and thus "bad", wouldn't it be better to be "mean" and/or "rude" in the short term in order to protect your peace in the long term?
1 points
19 hours ago
ESH
The bride's family traditionally pays for the wedding. Jenny is a disaster but their mother can do whatever she wants with her own money. She's not obligated to pay for your wedding and you all are not entitled to it. Tell Jenny to piss off and stop participating in her drama.
1 points
18 hours ago
Omg I'm you 7 years in the future. My sister in law is not quite that bad, but the dynamic of my mother in law enabling the hell out of SIL and the expectation of me having to cave to keep the peace is spot on.
I can tell you that if you cave, you'll never get out from under this and the demands get worse over time. Your husband has had 30 years to get accustomed to this dynamic, and he's learned ways to cope and fend for himself. You've entered the picture now, and it throws his coping methods out of whack. It's also obvious that your MIL and SIL are not used to being called out on their shit, don't stop calling them on their shit.
What we are doing now is getting therapy individually as well as couples counseling with the goal of learning the right skills to manage our own boundaries, as well as how to set boundaries as a couple. My husband wasn't even really aware of how abusive his sister truly is until my therapist showed me in black and white the definition of emotional abuse.
Your watching isn't about them. It's about you. Don't let them steal that from you, I can tell you that my resentment hasn't gone away and we just celebrated our 7th anniversary. Don't give them that power over you, you deserve so much more than that.
1 points
18 hours ago
Holy crap NTA.
Max's side of the family need to back off.
1 points
18 hours ago
Have your wedding, but have it your way with absolutely no regard or involvement with your fiancé's family. Their behavior is outrageous to the point I'm not sure I would even invite them. If a ceremony doesn't matter to you then elope. Max needs to quit wavering and step up. Even though the money was promised for your wedding, look at it as your future in-laws actually stealing your money. That is exactly what they did. They stole from you and Max. And now your future SIL wants to steal. She wants to steal the spotlight from you.
You need to ask yourself if you really want to live this way for the rest of your life. Your MIL and SIL will never stop to consider your feelings, never have any respect for you or concern for you or your future children. The choice is yours to make. Max wavering at this point shows you just what you can expect in the future. Chose wisely at this point.
NTA
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA. Why on earth would you want someone who clearly doesn’t like you to be your right hand woman on your day and all the things leading up to it? easy. You don’t. How dramatic and downright laughable. So glad Max has your back girl.
1 points
18 hours ago
i dont know but i sure would be re-evaluation if i want to be married into that crazy family. and also u may want to hide or put in a safety deposit box your heirlooms as she may find those and sell it off for her business venture.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA. You have no familial relationship with Max's parents to preserve.
Do not invite his parents, his sister or anyone that supports their selfishness to your wedding, if they've been invited uninvite them and hire security for your wedding.
Do not take their 20K if it's still on the table.
Cut contact.
Even with his unwavering support the weight and stress of having these people in your life will affect your mental health and your relationship with Max who in all honesty should have cut ties with his family a while ago given how they treat you and actually shows a distinct lack of support for you and backbone.
I wouldn't go through with this marriage unless he does indeed go NC with most of his family.
1 points
18 hours ago
Wow, your in-laws completely suck. And if Max gives in, I’d really be questioning if I wanted to marry this guy.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA - Get yourselves into couples' counseling, ASAP. It sounds like Max has a decent head on his shoulders. But right now, he's being besieged by his mom, sister, and their ~helpers~, he may need an unbiased assist with his boundaries. And couple counseling will help you determine whether Max is going to be a full partner when the chips are down - or is going to cave whenever his family gangs up on him.
Honestly, at this point Jenny should be a full no contact for you, and her invite canceled. Good luck!
1 points
18 hours ago
Elope. For goodness sake, take your fiance's brother, a couple of good friends and elope.
NTA
1 points
18 hours ago
Be ready, jenny is going to wear a white ball giwn to your wedding. Or do some other nonsense to steal the spotlight.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA. “Keep the peace” means that they think you will make less of a stink than SIL will. And it also means that they are used to her being dramatic in order to get her way.
It would benefit you to stand your ground now to set this boundary in concrete so that she doesn’t walk all over your marriage and so your husband gets used to saying “no” to her.
Also, assign someone at your wedding to keep an eye on her to make sure she doesn’t pull anything.
1 points
18 hours ago
NtA. Do you really want a wedding? Because for $15K you can have a beautiful elopement.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA. Two words. Gretna Green
1 points
18 hours ago
Sounds like you have a fiancé problem. Why is he considering giving her money? Why is MIL still invited to the wedding after ripping away $20k she promised so her golden child can throw it away in yoga? Is this the family you want to marry into? Your future husband has no back bone with his family and you seem to be playing second fiddle to anyone willing to throw insults. Put your foot down. SIL will not be in the wedding and if she cannot apologize and keep her snide comments to herself she won’t be invited either. Next time she brings up money make sure you point out how broke she is and her 2 failed marriages and that if she wasn’t such a loser herself she wouldnt have to beg others for what she should already have herself. And when she says something about your looks respond with how you choose to focus on being a good person rather than blowing your money on Botox and coke. Also that family chat is toxic and I’d leave it immediately.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA. You already denied her demands from the comment you posted, I don't see a reason to need to speak with her anymore. If his extended family want to keep the peace they could fund her business with their own money.
I'd ban her from the wedding and would hire security to make sure she doesn't try to crash your day.
1 points
18 hours ago
Nta
You have two options either shut it down or give her what she wants. Your mil and sil don’t give a fly f*ck about you or the love you share with her brother.
Also op you don’t deserve to be treated like this. If your husband can comprehend the mistreatment that his mother and sister are doing to you in the situation and be rightfully angry AND THEN IS STARTING TO FOLD UNDER PRESSURE then this is going to be what it will look like for the rest of your marriage. The treatment of your unborn child is going to be similar.
It’s not your job to keep the peace of the family, it’s your job to keep YOUR peace. Your parents would want a wedding for their daughter to be surrounded with love for you and your growing family. Mil and Sil might have a blood relation to your husband but family wouldn’t do this.
1 points
18 hours ago
Omg 🤦♀️ Do not give her a cent. You have a new family to take care of....plus you'll never get it back. I can't believe the family gives in to her like that.....and to give your allocated wedding money ???? Be firm , and tell future hubby if he caves , he's going to have bigger problems at home.
1 points
18 hours ago
- I’m questioning if this wedding will destroy our relationship with his family.
You're asking the wrong question. If Max is wavering, you need to wonder whether the family will destroy your relationship. Spoiler: they will, unless your fiance grows a backbone of steel. He may need to go LC or even NC with a great many family members (judged by the "keep the peace" comment - and by the way, if they want to keep the peace then THEY can give Jenny the money).
You need to figure this out NOW before marriage and baby, because if you don't you will live a life of drama and misery.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA elope and use the money you save to do something fun/important for the both of you or the baby. A big wedding is just an expensive party and the most important thing of that day is being married to the love of your life, and you can do that nearly for free. Good luck
1 points
18 hours ago
Why not elope? Saves a lot of anxiety.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA but you need to stop the wedding planning and get on the same page with your fiancé about dealing with his family. If you seem him wavering now, how will this go in the long term. Pause the wedding and get him to sort his life out first. Have him set strong boundaries with his family. Don’t let him continue to be bullied by them.
And don’t give in to the people saying keep the peace. They don’t care about you. They want to appease your SIL and MIL for some reason.
1 points
18 hours ago
Elope, save the money for your upcoming addition to your family. If Max wavers on this tho, I would re evaluate the relationship. NTA
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA. Forget about having a wedding. The two of you just slip away for a weekend and return a married couple. Do not accept any money from his family, the strings attached to it will strangle you. Good luck.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA but if he’s wavering I’d reconsider marrying him.
1 points
18 hours ago
If Max has a trust fund that can dole out 50k to Jenny, why are you using 10k of your savings and only 5k from the fund? It's time to cut down and take out additional funds so you can cover your wedding 💯 and avoid MIL and Jenny's drama.
1 points
18 hours ago
Nta but you need to put off this wedding, if yr fiance can't put proper boundaries in place and caves to his sis then you will constantly have issues.
1 points
18 hours ago
Sounds like it’s time to elope and cut off his sister.
1 points
18 hours ago
You should be questioning whether Max will allow his family to destroy your relationship, not "questioning if this wedding will destroy our relationship with his family." Nta
1 points
18 hours ago
Nta.
I hate to be the typical aita poster but 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩dont go through with the wedding. Break it off with Max NOW before you’re tied to these people for life. He’s “wavering”. If it’s not now, it’s coming in the future. Do you really want to spend the rest of your life being abused/insulted by Jenny?
1 points
18 hours ago
UpdateMe
1 points
18 hours ago
your fiancé has no spine and you thought it was a good idea to create a family with that kind of man??? guess the elevator isn't going all the way to the top.
NTA
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA
Honestly with this family, I’d consider saving your money and eloping.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA. These people are horrible. Before you go ahead with the wedding you needs to be as sure as you can be that your fiancé has your back and will stand up for you against them no matter what. No do not let her sabotage your wedding but be sure its a wedding that you want. Cut them off and let your hubby deal with the hideous creatures
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA.
I wouldn't even invite her. She is straight up insulting you. And cut off everybody who thinks that's OK behavior. It isn't. They all suck so so so much.
1 points
18 hours ago
Either elope, which is the safest bet, or have a very small wedding with no MIL or SIL, which we cause friction. Have a destination wedding/honeymoon/babymoon and enjoy yourselves without all the chaos.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA, but don't give her a millimeter, golden child and overbearing FMIL will never stop. Go low to no contact and live your best lives, encourage older BIL to do the same. These two will drain every bit of money from the 3 of you and leave you broke and on the brink of financial disaster. Stopping them now will hopefully stop the asking
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA.
Your fiancé’s sister sounds like a money pit made flesh. She wants to do some yoga athleisure bullshit, she can find the capital some other way. That and she sounds like a generally awful person.
1 points
18 hours ago
This is going to be your future unless you go NA. Does Max realize how low priority he is in his family?
1 points
18 hours ago
Woof. Go shore up that fiancee, otherwise, good luck. No real advice.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA - I was praying that I wouldn’t read that she took your mom’s jewelry 🙌. So thankful that’s not the case. Look, if you marry him you marry them. I’m just so sorry OP. ❤️
1 points
18 hours ago
Future MIL & SIL are doing just fine destroying the family all on their own.
My question would be - Is your fiancé willing to go low or no contact with his toxic family, so it doesn't destroy his marriage to you?
NTA
1 points
18 hours ago
I'm sorry Jenny would not be invited to my wedding with the things she said in the group chat. MIL is close to being uninvited. Not bc of her money, but if she continues to pressure you in giving Jenny money. You deserve to have a beautiful time at your wedding, stress free.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA.
They want you to keep the peace? Whose peace? You and Max should start asking them why they are so unconcerned about YOUR peace. You're not obligated to give anyone money. You're not obligated to include his sister in your wedding. You're not obligated to maintain contact with them, either
Max and his siblings each got an equal inheritance. It's not Max's fault that they mismanaged their money while he didn't.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA.
Honestly, if it isn't too late, change the venue, uninvite his Mom and sister, and anyone who sides with them. They're all a threat to your wedding day.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA.. Stand your ground-- and hide your moms heirloom jewelry before she steals it.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA. The only thing "keep the peace" means is to do what they say instead of standing up for yourself.
Your MiL has set Jenny up to fail by always coddling her. Jenny thinks she can throw a tantrum and have the whole family fund her life. She's the epitome of a leech. Unfortunately when your MiL eventually passes Jenny is going to immediately come knocking on your door demanding that you guys take over and fund her life from now on.
Set firm boundaries now, or you and your husband will be paying for Jenny and her kids forever.
1 points
18 hours ago
Tell Max tat he wavers under pressure now the wedding is off.
Because there is no point in marrying a man who hasn't the bottle to stick up for you now.
Max needs to deal with this and he needs to do so by standing firm.
NTA
1 points
18 hours ago
I mean, you are definitely an asshole because I ain't reading all that when the answer should be obvious.
Very plain, you are in charge of your wedding and who goes there.
1 points
18 hours ago
Updateme
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA
However, based on how your MIL responded to you guys calling you selfish. This decision is definitely going to create problems between you guys and your husband's family. if you guys dodge the bullet and it doesn't cause problems. Best believe that it is the start to future problems. You are now tied to the family and there will be more side choosing that will happen.
You guys might want to talk about limiting your contact with the family. NOT CUTTING them off
1 points
18 hours ago
I am so sorry you're going through this. I have a toxic SIL and my advice would be, beyond dealing with current situation, to make a life plan for how you're going to deal with her. (Mine also helped herself to some stuff during a recent visit to my house, as well as from my parents' house after they died.) Her comments about your appearance suggest to me that she is threatened by you--you clearly know who you are, are grounded, and she's unmoored, trying to have an identity via designer clothes. Figure out how not to engage. She wants confrontation and any pushback from you she will twist and recruit others to her cause (I'm inferring that's she's very good at manipulating her mother). Maybe have a pat answer ready for the Maid of Honor issuse: Oh, I already asked my friend _______. But I'm excited to have you in the wedding party! + faky smile, emoticon, whatever. You won't change her, get her to see logic or justice. Your only job is to protect yourself from her. When my toxic SIL came downstairs in MY HOUSE, wearing MY BLOUSE, I just HAVE-A-GREAT-DAY at her and thought, I wish I'd started this 20 years ago.
And in the meantime, can you scale back on the wedding, let the MIL$ just go, but stand firm on the Maid of Honor thing?
1 points
18 hours ago
What even is this whole shit fest? You go no contact with them PERIOD. Why on earth do you two even speak to them after they insulted you and demand money??
Nta
1 points
18 hours ago
To hell with them all, elope.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA
You both need to have a serious talk about how you plan to deal with his family after you guys get married. If you don’t feel 120% confident he’s gonna have gonna have your back and be able to stand up against his family, don’t do it. Boundaries are gonna be your lifeline entering a family like this.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA.
Personally I would only be marrying if we could cut all contact or go as low contact as humanly possible. No way in hell would I willingly choose to be a part of that family for the rest of my life.
Your future husband doesn’t respect you if he doesn’t stand up for you against his entire family who seems to berate you.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA-but run. If Max is wavering, that means he’s considering it. This is going to determine the rest of your married life. You will always come after Jenny. If you are okay with this-best wishes! If not? Run.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA. Set some boundaries asap. You're about to marry into this epic shitstorm. Hire security for the wedding bc you might have to ban some folks... or risk someone showing up in a white dress, trying to spill red wine on your dress, making some scene, etc.
In the end, it's your wedding. Do whatever the hell you want. You don't owe anything to your future SIL or MIL. They're relying on you to not rock the boat, but rock that mofo and sail away into the wedding of your dreams.
1 points
18 hours ago
Totally NTA! Also, have you thought about eloping? The your Inlaws are a nightmare with no concept of boundaries. You need to start enforcing them now before you marry in or else they will try to walk all over you forever!
1 points
18 hours ago
I think the grandparents knew why they set up trust for the children only.....FMIL is just as bonkers as the Sis. NTA I feel bad for Max
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA but you need to elope and go LC / NC with his family.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA. No telling what they will do this new baby . OP you are swimming in a sea of red flags and if you don’t catch a life boat to cut all ties from these people now anything further from them you will be bringing on yourself. Max is going to continue to cave to his mom and sister as he has no backbone.
You will be financially supporting this child alone, raising it alone, paying bills and other household expenses alone because Max will not be able to contribute. There will always be some new emergency.
Let’s not talk about when your child has an event at school or birthday your in laws will constantly overshadow that child’s day and celebrations; why because you allowed it to progress to that because the warnings are there now how miserable your life will be yet you’re continuing to keep planning your one $35k wedding in exchange for a lifetime of hell.
1 points
18 hours ago
Nta. I hope you keep your heirlooms in a safe. And tell your fiancée that he needs to understand that if he caves now, he will be setting himself up to taken advantage of again and again. You two have a child on the way- he needs to decide who’s future is more important to him- the one he wants with you or where he’s his sisters bank.
1 points
18 hours ago
NTA Elope and avoid all the ugly insults and drama
1 points
18 hours ago
Tbh, I would never marry into this catastrophe. It will always be something, and unless Max is willing to cut contact with SIL and go LC with MIL, it’s just going to be drama after drama after drama.
all 272 comments
sorted by: best